
On March 1, CBCNews.ca published a feature article whose headline carried the unsubstantiated and egregious allegations that: “Israeli attacks have left 17,000 orphans in Gaza.”

The article by CBC journalists Chris Brown, Lily Martin, & Yasmine Hassan, along with Gaza-based freelancer Mohamed El Saife, reported the following in the lead paragraph:
“UNICEF, the United Nations Children’s Fund, has estimated that 17,000 children have been left either orphaned or separated from their parents because of the war. The creation of so many fractured childhoods and parentless children has emerged as one of the most harrowing humanitarian challenges of the five month old conflict.”
According, there were two errors in this article:
1) The war itself has led to 17,000 children being separated OR orphaned, not that Israeli attacks have caused there to be 17,000 orphans in Gaza. This distinction is important as some of these Palestinian children’s parents may have been combatants or who were killed by errant or even intentional fire by Palestinian terrorist’s gunfire or rocket fire. Israel says that over 1,000+ rockets misfired and landed prematurely in Gaza, killing and maiming scores of Palestinians.
2) An orphan means a child whose parents were killed. For its part, UNICEF said these children were either orphaned OR separated from their parents. In other words, they are not all orphans as CBC described.
In light of this information, on March 1, HonestReporting Canada called on CBC to correct its false reporting. To its credit, CBC immediately corrected its article whose headline now states: “This boy — one of thousands orphaned in Gaza — hopes Canada will let him start over”.

While we appreciate that CBC took corrective action, however, given the egregious and unsubstantiated accusations CBC made against Israel, and in accordance with our public broadcaster’s journalistic standards and practices, we asked that a formal correction notice be published and appended to this article in the interests of transparency and accountability. As of this writing, CBC has failed to publish a correction notice which runs counter to the CBC’s requirement to be accountable to Canadians and transparent in their editorial process.
Furthermore, we asked CBC to liaise with its colleagues at RCI to ensure that their headline is also corrected.

Regrettably and as of this writing, no corrective action has been undertaken by RCI who article still claims that “Israeli attacks have left 17,000 orphans in Gaza. One boy hopes Canada will let him start over”.
Stay tuned to this page for future updates.






