When the fanatical Iranian regime spends decades and untold sums constructing ballistic missiles and pursuing a nuclear weapons program, in addition to funding and arming an array of Islamic terrorist groups across the Middle East, some commentators nevertheless call it “stability.”
But when Israel – the target of the regime’s genocidal vision – decides to defend itself, alongside American assistance, such moves are condemned as reckless and “unlawful,” apparently claiming that bad actors can do as they see fit, and only when they are met with a response is it a problem.
Two opinion columns in The Toronto Star, both published within hours of war breaking out in Iran, appeared to make that absurd argument.
Lloyd Axworthy, a one-time foreign minister under Prime Minister Jean Chretien, penned a column, “Canada once rejected America’s aggressive, unlawful foreign policy. Today Mark Carney embraced it,” where he condemned Prime Minister Mark Carney for publicly supporting the strikes on the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Axworthy argues that the strikes were contrary to international law because the threat by Iran was not “imminent,” and because it did not receive the blessing of the United Nations Security Council.
This worldview – that Israel should rely on its existence from a body that includes regimes like China and Russia, both allies of Iran – is an argument from the benefit of the safety of Canada, where Axworthy can lecture Israel. In reality, Israel cannot trust a body where China and Russia enjoy veto power.
As for the imminent threat, Iran has amassed thousands of ballistic missiles, which are individually able to devastate a city block in Israel. For a country smaller than Vancouver Island, they most definitely represent an immediate threat, particularly from a regime that threatens to destroy Israel.
The same day, Justin Ling, a staff columnist for The Toronto Star whose anti-Israel animus and casual misrepresentation of the facts has long been on full display, authored his own commentary, “Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu have made a dangerous gamble in Iran. Why is Mark Carney cheering them on?,” in what was a close carbon copy of Axworthy’s column, minus the professional credibility and experience.
Ling dismissed the strikes as an “immoral gamble” and condemned Carney’s endorsement of them, claiming that only a negotiated settlement with Iran could have avoided conflict. It is here that Ling demonstrates a breathtaking lack of understanding about Iran’s leaders. Whether on the topic of ballistic missiles, the nuclear program or its support for proxy groups, Iran’s leaders are devoted to their radical ideology, chiefly the destruction of Israel. Any negotiations which harm that goal are dead on arrival. It is simply impossible to negotiate in good faith with a party that cannot be rationally convinced to abandon its murderous plans.
Ling spread the claims that an American strike hit a school “killing at least 80,” without bothering to note that the allegations and death toll are both completely unverified.
Ling ended his column by stating that “we should cheer when the brutal Iranian regime falls.” However, in the real world, regimes like Tehran’s do not fall by themselves, and when the Iranian people try and protest, they are mowed down en masse.
The Israeli-American operation may have many flaws, but there can be no question that toppling the Iranian regime, both for the safety of the Iranian people and those across the Middle East and beyond, is an eminently reasonable goal.
Then on March 3, the newspaper added another, familiar voice: Amanda Ghahremani, a criminal lawyer who has previously signed a hateful anti-Israel open letter which we see as justifying Hamas terrorism. She begins her column, “Iran’s oppressive regime shaped my life, and my family’s. I’m afraid of where Donald Trump’s war will lead,” with a perfunctory condemnation of the Iranian regime, before condemning Israel for actually striking that regime, spreading the completely unverified claim that “hundreds of civilians” have been killed, relying on none other than the regime she purports to assail.
And true to confirm, the same day, The Toronto Star published another longtime anti-Israel commentator: Faisal Kutty, a Toronto lawyer who previously tried to claim that white supremacists – not Islamic terrorists – pose a bigger threat to Canadians.
His column, “International law does not dissolve because a regime is objectionable,” by assuring readers that he believes the Iranian regime is repressive, before pivoting to his real opponent: Israel, claiming that no attack on Tehran is permissible unless the UN Security Council says so. This logic would have Israel at the whims of Russia and China, two Iranian allies with veto power on that world body, meaning that under no circumstances in Kutty’s mind would Israel actually be able to defend itself under his perception of the law.
And again on the same day, Axworthy was back with another column, “Mark Carney’s government needs to give us the full truth about our involvement in Iran,” accusing Israel and the US of “rolling the dice on regional escalation,” making no real acknowledgement of the ongoing threat from Iran.
The Toronto Star could have chosen to offer a balanced perspective on the war with Iran. It did not. Instead, it relied on four commentators with well-documented histories of lambasting Israel, Lloyd Axworthy, Faisal Kutty, Ghahremani and Justin Ling, with columns that displayed a striking ignorance about the reality of the Middle East.
In fact, the only column in the entire batch that was broadly even-handed was from columnist Martin Regg Cohn, “Mark Carney is caught in the same balancing act as other world leaders on Iran,” where he acknowledged the “theocratic and terroristic regime in Iran,” while noting competing pressures on Ottawa.
The Toronto Star, long a bastion of anti-Israel disinformation in the Canadian news media, has shown little interest in providing its readers with a full picture of events in the Middle East.






