Toronto Star Columnist Justin Ling Calls International Criminal Court “Crown Jewel” Of International Law, Disregarding Its Long History Of Anti-Israel Animus

As noted by international law expert Natasha Hausdorff, the two-year war between Hamas and Israel in Gaza was a vivid example of the weaponization of international law targeting Jerusalem.

As Hausdorff has observed, the fixation by international bodies like the International Criminal Court (ICC) against Israel represents “a concerted effort to promote anti-Israel agendas, effectively rewriting the rule book of international law.”

However, rather than deal with the serious charges of institutional anti-Israel agendas among these international fora, a recent Toronto Star column simply accepted at face value that these bodies are beyond reproach, and any challenge against them represents a full-frontal assault on international law.

In a January 30 opinion column, “Donald Trump is attacking a Canadian judge. Mark Carney has the power to stop him,” featured staff columnist Justin Ling lambasting the United States for daring to sanction ICC judge Kimberly Prost for her role in targeting Israeli officials, saying that it represented an attack on international law itself.

A thoughtful commentary could have listened to criticisms of the ICC, and whether the body could be considered credible or not, and addressed them meaningfully. But Ling did no such thing, instead appearing to blindly accept that the world court is “the crown jewel of our system of international law,” taking it as self-evident.

As a body of the United Nations, the ICC relies on previous resolutions to help it develop its rulings. In 2021, the ICC cited dozens of different United Nations resolutions to help it arrive at its conclusion that ‘Palestine’ is a state. The fact that, at the United Nations General Assembly, anti-Israel resolutions are effectively guaranteed to pass by virtue of the demographics of countries represented, simply does not matter; the truth takes a back seat to politics.

As Hillel Neuer of UN Watch has pointed out, the ICC has never issued any arrest warrant for Ali Khamenei, the supreme leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran, nor for any other terrorist as part of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).

Ling’s column also ignores any mention of allegations that Karim Khan, the ICC’s chief prosecutor, may have targeted Israel in a blatant attempt to distract from his own sexual misconduct allegations from multiple women, including a direct subordinate.

The closest that Ling came to acknowledging the longstanding and well-documented anti-Israel animus of the court is when he quoted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accusing the ICC of being “motivated by an antisemitic hatred of Israel.”

By no stretch is this a fair assessment of the criticisms against the ICC, and instead amounts to little more than a straw man argument by Ling, presenting a single statement and ignoring reams of evidence showing that the ICC has exhibited a long history of antagonism towards Jerusalem.

This is not the first time that Justin Ling has misrepresented international law in an effort to target Israel. In a July, 2025 column in The Toronto Star, he repeatedly treated provisional findings from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) as confirmed legal findings, and falsely claimed that the court demanded that Israel suspend its military activities, when it did no such thing. He also called for Ottawa to intervene against Israel.

In an earlier column published in April, 2025, Ling claimed that Israel’s targeting of hospitals in Gaza “makes a mockery of international law.” Following an HonestReporting Canada complaint to The Toronto Star that pointed out Hamas’ use of these facilities removes their protected status under the Geneva Conventions, the newspaper issued a correction and an editor’s note.

Rather than accept a childlike, unquestioning faith in the International Criminal Court, Toronto Star columnist Justin Ling would do well to recognize that the court’s longtime anti-Israel agenda raises serious questions about its credibility.

Comments