Three CBC News Reports Use Heavy Emotion To Peddle Famine Fiction

September 5, 2025

CBC News’ disinformation campaign against Israel has reached a fever pitch, with new coverage inching closer to dropping all pretense of being objective reporting and becoming overt anti-Israel propaganda.

In a September 3 broadcast and accompanying “analysis” article, Foreign Correspondent Chris Brown, a regular disseminator of biased anti-Israel reporting, used the story of a 17-year-old Gazan, Ahmed Ali al-Batniji, to level repeated accusations against Jerusalem for allegedly starving the population there.

The broadcast titled: “Gaza teen explains what it’s like to starve,” left no doubt as to the agenda-driven reporting, zeroing in on the skeletal al-Batniji and using it as supposed evidence for Israeli malfeasance. Brown teamed up with Mohamed El Saife, CBC’s “freelance videographer” in Gaza and an anti-Israel propagandist to produce this feature-length report broadcast on its flagship program, The National.

Click below to watch the segment:

While Brown’s report did briefly acknowledge images of largesse inside Gaza, and evidence that many individuals appearing to starve are in fact suffering from other diseases, they were presented incredibly briefly and sandwiched between extended interviews with guests accusing Israel of seeking to starve Gaza.

Brown even made the unfounded allegation (and disguised his personal opinion as news) by saying that Israel is “smearing” critics to discredit famine accusations. He said (emphasis added): “… Israel’s efforts to discredit famine accusations have included smearing those who’ve died by suggesting underlying health problems were more relevant than the lack of food.”

Brown had no problem heavily relying on claims by “local health authorities” and the “Gaza Health Ministry” as supposedly authoritative sources to buttress casualty claims of those allegedly dead due to malnutrition, hunger and starvation and those allegedly killed at aid sites and in the conflict over the course of the past two years. He never informed CBC readers and viewers that his source is the Hamas terrorist organization! As former Jerusalem Post editor Yaakov Katz has argued, “If we accept the number of people that Hamas claims have been killed in this war and let’s be honest for a second, after 9/11 and it was (former) President Biden who said that October 7 was fifteen 9/11’s for the State of Israel and after 9/11, if the Al Qaeda Health Ministry had come out and made claims of the numbers of casualties in Afghanistan, would the New York Times or any other newspaper publish them? I don’t’ think so…”

The distinct impression given to viewers by Brown is that virtually no aid is entering Gaza, overlooking that literally hundreds of trucks filled with humanitarian aid entered the territory the day prior to Brown’s report and disregarding aid theft by Hamas and armed gangs.

But such evidence takes a backseat to an emotional story about a teenager appearing to starve, even as his entire family around him has enough food and look healthy. Though Brown acknowledged that al-Batniji has Celiac disease, which is a serious autoimmune disorder, his report portrayed Israel as cruelly and intentionally starving the teenager and other Palestinians.

Accompanying Brown’s video broadcast was a news article published on September 4 entitled: “As hunger grows in Gaza, warnings that starvation hits the most vulnerable first,” though the wording was previously even more direct in its explicit condemnation of Israel, initially reading as “Why starving Gaza is never going to defeat Hamas.”

In the article, Brown quoted the United Nations-affiliated Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), which he called “the world’s foremost authority on food insecurity,” and stated that it “declared a famine in Gaza City.” Despite extensive criticisms pointing out that in Gaza, the IPC radically changed its definition of what constitutes famine to suit its needs, Brown made no mention of these critiques whatsoever, leaving readers with a brutally incomplete and skewed picture.

Brown’s article said that: “Last March, Israel imposed a near-total blockade of food and humanitarian supplies coming into Gaza,” yet again ignoring that the short blockade lasting only a few weeks was preceded by a massive boost in aid that experts said provided for nearly half a year’s worth of food, meaning that there was never any actual shortage inside Gaza.

Once again, that was ignored in favour of a narrative so simplified that it crossed the border into overt disinformation.

And while Brown (briefly) stated that Israel has accused Hamas of stealing aid, he stated that “Western aid agencies have said Israel has overstated the amount of aid Hamas has stolen or been able to divert,” casually ignoring that even by the United Nations’ own data, almost 90 percent of the aid it delivers into the territory gets stolen.

While it is unclear how much of that is stolen by Hamas specifically versus other armed gangs, the conclusion is unavoidable: that theft of aid is a rampant problem dramatically downplayed by Brown and the CBC.

Brown’s reports were far from the only recent instances of CBC News using emotionally-heavy images to tell a story in place of factual evidence.

On September 3, CBC Chief Correspondent Adrienne Arsenault showed images of an emaciated girl, using her as more evidence of starvation, while ignoring that standing beside her is her mother, not appearing to lack for any food. Leading to the possible conclusion that the child may have a pre-existing condition. Yet viewers are presumably supposed to pretend otherwise.

Click below to watch the segment:

These three reports by Chris Brown and Adrienne Arsenault are not responsible story-telling, but irresponsible yellow journalism, relying on crass sensationalism to replace sober facts and evidence, all on the taxpayers dime.

Comments