Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, a Toronto Member of Parliament (MP) who publicly whined that he felt “disrespected” by Prime Minister Mark Carney when he was dropped from cabinet, has found a new topic in which to complain: that the Carney government is insufficiently hostile to Israel.
In a September 5 opinion column in The Toronto Star entitled: “Canada must act on Gaza – including more sanctions on Israel,” Erskine-Smith demanded that the Carney government implement more harsh anti-Israel steps, including recognizing a Palestinian state, implementing an arms embargo, and sanctioning the Jewish State, saying that “we cannot be complicit in Israel’s crimes.”
While he gave a nod to Palestinian terrorism that began the war, he rattled off a litany of half-truths to justify his attack on Jerusalem, writing that “There is no world in which the Hamas terrorist attack of Oct. 7 justifies emaciated Palestinian kids.”
He is correct that the Palestinian massacres of October 7, 2023 would not justify “emaciated Palestinian kids,” yet he failed to understand that what he took as unassailable truth is, in fact, complete fiction. Despite claims from some corners that there is “famine” in Gaza – in fact, he began the column by saying that “the UN has officially declared a famine in Gaza” – he showed a remarkable lack of critical thinking.
He ignored the veritable mountain of humanitarian aid entering Gaza every single day, ignored footage showing well-stocked markets and restaurants inside the territory, and pretended that the recent United Nations declaration didn’t dramatically change what constitutes “famine,” singularly so Gaza can be categorized as such.
Instead, he gullibly accepted United Nations claims as truth, disregarding any and all facts to the contrary.
Erskine-Smith also told readers that “we’ve watched Israel’s mass and indiscriminate killing of innocent Palestinian civilians,” a powerful image, except that Canadians haven’t actually “watched” such events; they’ve heard powerful anti-Israel groups make those claims, wholly without evidence.
Israel has not engaged in “indiscriminate killing” in Gaza, an absurd claim to which Erskine-Smith did not even pretend to provide evidence for; rather, Jerusalem has taken more pains to minimize civilian casualties than any other military in modern history.
That is not a matter of opinion, but of demonstrated fact, as noted by the world’s leading scholar of urban warfare, John Spencer of the West Point military institute. Israel has taken steps – and sacrificed its own soldiers’ lives – in order to avoid unnecessary harm to Palestinian civilians, even as the Hamas terrorist group actively seeks to maximize death inside Gaza by situating its fighters in civilian areas so as to create an avalanche of negative headlines around the world for Israel.
Rather than recognizing Palestinian fanaticism as the core of the conflict, Erskine-Smith has instead decided to take the easy route by blaming Israel almost exclusively.
This is part of an ongoing pattern on his part. Over the last two years, Erskine-Smith has made a name for himself as an increasingly vocal anti-Israel activist. During the 2025 election, he signed a “Vote Palestine” pledge, and was one of the seven percent of its signatories not to lose in the subsequent election, and in early 2024, he voted in favour of a resolution in Parliament sponsored by hardline anti-Israel NDP member Heather McPherson.
Nathaniel Erskine-Smith’s opinion column is not a serious contribution to public discourse, but a sophomoric attack on Israel aimed at scoring easy political points with sympathetic Toronto Star readers.






