McGill University Newspaper The Tribune Amplifies Extremist Anti-Israel Rhetoric, Treats Falsehoods As Facts

April 7 was a busy day for McGill University’s student society outlet, The Tribune. Its edition covered various topics and events related to the anti-Israel movement and antisemitism on McGill campus.

Yusur Al-Sharqi’s report on “McGill investigating antisemitic vandalism in Faculty of Medicine” covered the discovery and response of antisemitic vandalism in a Faculty of Medicine bathroom that said, “Kill all Jews” and “Jews out of McGill Med.”

Amelia H. Clark’s news article covered how the Law Student Association’s “Referendum to boycott Israeli institutions passes with the highest voting turnout in recent LSA history.” Clark explored the implications of the vote, and the circumstances surrounding the Provost and Executive Vice-President Academic’s and Dean of Law’s letter calling the amendment discriminatory toward Jewish students. Clark interviewed four representatives from Law Students for Palestine at McGill (LS4PM) for her story.

Sofia Sada provided a commentary on “The pattern behind [Rima] Hassan’s denial of entry” into Canada, framing the issue of the extremist French politician’s ban as suppression of free expression and the rise of censorship related to the Israel-Hamas war.

Two core aspects of these reports are the treatment of disinformation and historical revisionism, treating them as incontestable the minimization of the mainstream Jewish community (and the discrimination it continues to face) and disproportionate platforming of anti-Zionist perspectives.

Clark’s report, for example, makes no distinction between fact and opinion when explaining the LS4PM’s call to terminate academic ties with Israeli institutions “complicit in Israel’s ongoing genocide in Palestine” and the “targeted bombing of all 12 universities in Palestine and the killing of thousands of students and professors.”

Sada’s commentary on French-Palestinian European Member of Parliament Rima Hassan’s denial of entry into Canada is contextualized with Sada’s explanation of “Canadian mainstream media [manipulating] language to minimize or misrepresent the genocide, excluding Palestinian voices.” Sada quotes a scholar that describes this exclusion as “[perpetuating a colonial dynamic where ‘the native cannot speak for themselves’.”

Rather than making the case for free expression, Sada moralizes the motivations surrounding Hassan’s denial of entry by describing her lack of entry as an “[obstruction that maintains] colonial power dynamics where dissenting voices are intentionally suppressed.”

The second core issue is the minimization of mainstream Canadian Jewry. This is predominantly seen in Clark and Al-Sharqi’s articles.

Al-Sharqi reports how the graffiti incident “is raising renewed concerns about campus safety for Jewish students,” and quotes a spokesman for McGill denouncing the incident. The Medicine and Dentistry Jewish Association’s official statement is also quoted, and since The Tribune contacted the association and other mainstream organizations – saying they did not “respond in time” – Independent Jewish Voices (IJV) is given an extensive platform instead. Left untold, Independent Jewish Voices (IJV) is a fringe organization that has been accused of rationalizing Hamas terrorism and engaging in Holocaust denial.

IJV’s stance is that the university’s legitimizing the equivalence between anti-Zionism and antisemitism through structures in place to address discrimination is a “transgression [that] imposes itself far more heavily on our community’s conscience than Sharpie in bathroom stalls.” Simply, the onus is on the school for complying with the mainstream definition of antisemitism, rather than medical students for professing their desire for Jewish students to be gone or dead.

Most of Clark’s article deals with the accusations of interference with the referendum vote on the administration’s part, rather than the heart of the referendum itself. A statement, from the chair of the Faculty’s Advisory Board that resigned because of the referendum, is quoted, accusing McGill of being “an environment where being Jewish, identifying as a Zionist, or maintaining any association with the State of Israel carries professional and personal risk.”

Members of the LS4PM, on the other hand, criticized responses from Jewish students and aforementioned leaders concerned with the safety of Jewish students: “There’s a lot of language that the community feels unsafe… Jewish students have this unfair burden. Jewish faculty feel unsafe… [There have been] no reports of intimidation or discrimination.”

These LS4PM members push back against accusations of antisemitism by saying that members of the group, and supporters of the referendum, are Jewish, and that the impact of the referendum will not be felt by individuals.

At the heart of each of the three articles is the lived reality of most of McGill University’s Jewish students, faculty and staff: the antisemitism that has bubbled and spilled over.

And rather than taking a hard look at the reason why the “Palestine” issue is repeatedly pushed back at by institutional powers and leaders; rather than concretely address instances or accusations of antisemitism as part of a wider issue, not merely listing instances of antisemitism that “[reflect] a broader nationwide trend” with no further interrogation, as Al-Sharqi does – The Tribune contributors revert to the increasingly common trend of undermining antisemitism in the name of whatever cause is mainstream.

The trend of morally-derived, misinformed activism has seeped into student journalism; how consequential events and actions are reported have consequences, and Jewish students, faculty and staff in Canada’s institutions are bearing the brunt of it.

Comments