In a new low for The McGill Daily, the student newspaper at Montreal’s McGill University, has published a sympathetic interview with a local anti-Israel activist, Giancarlo Cininni, where he openly justified Hamas’s terrorist massacres on October 7, 2023.
The March 16 article, “On the Ground in the West Bank: A Testimony with Giancarlo Cininni,” was written by Culture Editor Youmna El Halabi, a regular purveyor of anti-Israel propaganda at the newspaper. She has previously fawningly profiled one anonymous Montreal protester who sees “political or armed resistance (as) an act of obedience to Allah.”
In her profile of Cininni, El Halabi writes that he was a volunteer with the International Solidarity Movement (ISM), a group with a history of justifying Palestinian terrorism, and which critics note has also had ties to Palestinian terrorist groups.
El Halabi calls Cininni a “freelance journalist based in Halifax,” having graduated from King’s College during the non-existent “Gaza genocide in 2023,” and mentions his upbringing during what she calls “the 9/11 incident.”
El Halabi’s casual sanitization of Islamic terrorism by calling the murder of three thousand people on American soil “the 9/11 incident” was just a taste of what was to come. She then quotes Cininni as saying that “I would say October 7th was probably worse [in regard to scapegoating] because the context of the Hamas attacks was very much in line with [resisting the oppressor]. There was the Great March of Return in 2019 and other struggles. Anybody with a brain would be like, ‘[Gaza’s resistance] is a powder keg waiting to explode’. It’s only a matter of time. And there’s strategic significance to the actions on October 7th, what with the normalization happening.”
What Cininni characterized as resistance was in fact murderous and medieval barbarism, carried out by Hamas terrorists, and accompanied by ordinary Palestinian civilians. After carrying out a bestial campaign of rape, murder, torture and kidnappings, the bodies of Israeli civilians were paraded into Gaza, where they were met, not with outrage from Gazans, but with cheers.
In fact, terrorism and the murder of Israelis have been widely popular inside Gaza, and a poll in late 2023 found a large majority of Palestinians there supported the October 7 mass murders.
El Halabi later quotes him as saying that “anybody with a brain would be like, ‘[Gaza’s resistance]’ is a powder keg waiting to explode.’” In this twisted retelling, the alleged oppression of Gaza somehow justified deliberately targeting civilians in Israel for murder. Yet in other cases of actual oppression, such as the Holocaust, large numbers of Jews did not seek the mass murder of German and other civilian populations.
But in Cininni’s retelling, laundered sympathetically by El Halabi, Gazans are evidently unable to control themselves to the point that they simply cannot keep themselves from carrying out crimes against humanity.
This overt justification of terrorism in the pages of The McGill Daily is despicable, but hardly a surprise given the increasing radicalization seen among a number of Canadian student newspapers. While Youmna El Halabi was the author of this piece, the responsibility does not lie exclusively with her, but with Managing Editor Sena Ho and other editors.
While the publication calls itself “an independent student newspaper,” it has extensive ties to McGill University, spelled out in an official memorandum which notes that the school collects fees from the university’s student body, and then disburses it to The McGill Daily four times per year.
If The McGill Daily will not take responsibility for publishing content that openly justifies the mass murder of civilians, then McGill University must step in and take immediate corrective action.






