Hill Times Column By Retired Civil Servant Bhagwant Sandhu Defends Rewarding Terrorism With Statehood

In his September 15 opinion column in The Hill Times entitled: “Gaza is testing Canada’s moral compass, and Carney’s credibility,” retired civil servant Bhagwant Sandhu continued a pattern familiar to readers of his work: a sharp moral framing that consistently casts Israel as villain and demands that Canada take a more adversarial stance toward it.

HonestReporting Canada has previously highlighted this tendency, including in its detailed rebuttal of Sandhu’s past column for relying on Hamas-supplied casualty figures and one-sided narratives. This latest piece was no exception.

Sandhu wrote that “Carney’s willingness to acknowledge Palestine departs from past postures,” but lamented that Canada’s criticisms of Israel remain “mostly muted.” One might think, reading Sandhu’s column, that Canada’s primary foreign policy obligation is to appease international anti-Israel NGOs and social media sentiment rather than to craft a responsible, security-conscious position that discourages terrorism.

The core problem with Sandhu’s framing is that it treats Hamas, the governing power in Gaza and the very architect of this war, as an afterthought. Hamas’ October 7, 2023 massacre, which deliberately targeted civilians, launched this conflict and the terror group continues to perpetuate it by refusing to disarm, disband and release dozens of Israeli hostages. Yet Sandhu demanded Canada reward that violence with the symbolic prize of statehood recognition. That isn’t moral clarity, but moral amnesia. Terrorism cannot be rewarded with legitimacy. Doing so is like giving in to a child’s tantrum and expecting the behaviour to improve.

Sandhu cited Gaza’s Health Ministry casualty figures as unassailable facts. This is curious, given that the health ministry is controlled by Hamas, the same group that faked mass casualty counts during previous conflicts, as even the UN’s own reporting has had to quietly revise when challenged. A more rigorous column would have at least acknowledged that these numbers are not independently verified and are part of a propaganda war designed to erode international support for Israel.

The column also leaned heavily on the language of genocide, pointing to statements by “Holocaust experts” and the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS) as if these were definitive verdicts. But citing the IAGS is not exactly the intellectual trump card Sandhu seems to think it is.

This is an organization that will happily sell anyone a membership for roughly forty dollars – no peer-reviewed publications required. Its roster reportedly includes household pets and even Emperor Palpatine of Star Wars. If this is the gold standard of “genocide scholarship,” then he might as well convene the Jedi Council to pass judgment on Israel’s military strategy. Sandhu’s casual deployment of the term “genocide” to describe a defensive war against a group openly committed to Israel’s annihilation isn’t sober analysis, it’s rhetorical theatre. It trivializes both real genocides and real scholarship by turning one of the gravest charges in international law into a talking point that happens to align with Hamas’ propaganda playbook.

Sandhu argued that Canada’s arms exports to Israel and its reluctance to condemn Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu more harshly represent a moral failing. But what he called “equivocation” might also be described as balance – supporting an ally under attack while insisting on humanitarian access for civilians. Unfortunately, that balance has now tipped.

Ottawa’s recent decision to officially recognize the state of Palestine is less a triumph of moral clarity than a case study in political capitulation. By granting recognition in the middle of an active conflict, Canada has effectively rewarded Hamas’ October 7 massacre and subsequent hostage-taking with the legitimacy it has long sought. This is not diplomacy – it is surrender to the loudest protests and the most persistent propaganda. It is, quite literally, giving in to the noise and the tantrums and then expecting better behaviour in return.

Perhaps the most striking feature of Sandhu’s column is its faith that international recognition of Palestinian statehood – delivered while rockets are still being fired at Israel – would advance peace. In reality, such a move entrenches Hamas’ rule, rewards hostage-taking, and sends a clear message to every other armed group in the world: violence works. History shows that durable peace agreements come from negotiation, not unilateral recognition granted under fire.

Sandhu closed by urging Canada to act, because “history won’t wait, but it will remember which side we were on.” He’s right about one thing: history will remember. But it should also remember that moral clarity means refusing to normalize terrorism, no matter how compelling the headlines or how loud the protests.

Comments