Hamilton Spectator Gaza Op-Ed High On Rhetoric, Low On Facts

September 2, 2025

Margaret Shkimba’s August 26 column in the Hamilton Spectator, “Let the international media into Gaza,” read less like journalism, and more like advocacy. She didn’t just swipe at Israel — she downplayed the atrocities of Oct 7, 2023, leaned on selective facts, and sidesteped the full weight of credible evidence. For a writer who professes to value “truth,” the omissions did most of the talking. But then, the author’s biased record should give readers an indication of what direction the commentary will take.

She exclaimed how the “outrageous stories of beheaded babies and rapes” stemming from the Oct 7, 2023 massacre were “embellishment.” A “because” wasn’t provided.

Per the widespread rapes and other sexual assaults, it seems like she’s not done her homework. Co-sponsored by the UK Government, the Dinah Project’s 84-page report, “A Quest for Justice: October 7 and Beyond,” is a full research paper that she owes it to herself to read. The burden is on Shkimba to show how, and where, there was an “embellishment.” Perhaps Shkimba has a competing study than the one spearheaded here by Ruth Halperin-Kadari, who served for twelve years on the UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), including multiple terms as its Vice-Chair.

The babies story, worth a deeper look, reveals that in the first 72 hours or so of the Hamas-led attack on Israel, disparate pieces of data trickled out from official and non-official sources. This was still all within the fog of early chaos, combined with some misreporting. Eventually, the Israeli government issued clarifications – but Shkimba fails to mention that.

Of course, one wonders if she was OK with “embellishments” of the some 500 who Hamas claimed – almost instantly – were killed at the Al-Ahli Hospital in Oct. 2023’s rocket attack. To their great shame, much of the world media gobbled it up unquestioningly, including blaming Israel for the strike. Human Rights Watch eventually conceded that the casualties were highly inflated – not to mention that the rocket originated from Palestinian Islamic Jihad.

Shkimba then fired off a damning charge: “A (Gazan) child being blown up gathering water.” It appears the reader is led to conclude this all came from the bloodthirsty, inhumane, and genocidal Israeli army, not a drop of conscience among them. She (conveniently) provided no context. For those unaware, in a July incident, an IDF missile malfunction caused collateral damage that was supposed to have taken out terrorists dozens of meters away. A tragedy, yes, but hardly a deliberate one.

While Shkimba railed against “propagandists” – the way in which her “fact drop” was framed, is precisely what propagandists do: intentional errors of omission, advertent missing context, and purposeful disregard for the opposing view. Even if she thinks the Israeli point of view is irrelevant or incorrect, she had a journalistic duty to mention it. That is, if she’s the stickler for truth that she boasts she is. She said in the piece: “But we have a duty to look at these pictures of death and destruction. A duty to face the truth.” However, pictures do not ever tell the full story; rather, they show a snapshot, a moment in time. They certainly are not, in and of themselves, “the truth.” The truth comes with a rigorous examination and full investigation of all sides.

Alas, when there are reportedly so many propagandists and terrorists masquerading as journalists, even pictures in this war must notbe taken at face value, as we’ve seen with the recent New York Times fiasco regarding 18-month-old Mohammad al-Mutawaq – not suffering from starvation, as we’re led to believe, but rather suffering from cerebral palsy.

In a rant about on-the-ground media, the author made a number of wild and damning claims – none of which hold water. For example: “the number of journalists targeted and killed by Israel is astounding; upwards of 200. Not just journalists, but their families as well. We will be told they were all working for Hamas. Israel is erasing the evidence and controlling the narrative, one dead journalist at a time.” The Committee to Protect Journalists’ statistics says that as of Aug. 28, 2025, 197 journalists were killed in the conflict in West Bank, Gaza and Lebanon (not “upwards of 200”, and not all in Gaza). As the Wall Street Journal notes (and despite what Shkimba might prefer), there are no independent journalists in these areas – all are beholden to their propagandist handlers, including but not limited to Hamas-affiliated Al-Aqsa TV.

Shkimba presents zero evidence that “upwards of 200” were “targeted and killed by Israel” as she claims, never mind their families too. Shkimba ignores that many of these so-called “journalists” were Hamas operatives or not even members of the media in the first place. There are inherent risks and dangers of being a journalist in a densely-populated urban war zone (especially when one embeds themselves with Hamas — the target of Israeli strikes), but in her mind, none of those factors affected any reporters for the past two years.

It’s not just Shkimba’s commentaries that bear out easy-to-Google flaws and violations of common sense journalism. Her X feed is a cornucopia of anti-Israel propaganda. In one concerning post, she wrote about “the chattering classes who continue to defend Israel’s right to kill everything that moves in Gaza.” She’s retweeted from Order of Canada recipient Mohamad Fakih, who said that those who support Israel “do not support basic human values.” Mind you, there wasn’t a qualifier like “Israeli military” or “Israeli government” or “Israeli policy.” This is both of them describing a liberal Western democracy, but they’re both mum on his beloved Lebanon, who Freedom House characterizes as a vast-reaching human rights nightmare half as free as Israel.

In the end, Shkimba’s column offered more heat than light — a patchwork of omissions, exaggerations, and outright distortions dressed up as “truth.” By minimizing Hamas’s atrocities, recycling discredited claims, and casting Israel as uniquely villainous, she undermined not only her own credibility but also the integrity of journalism itself. Readers deserve analysis grounded in evidence, not propaganda masquerading as moral clarity.

September 2, 2025
September 2, 2025

Comments