Globe & Mail Film Reviewer Barry Hertz Targets Israel Again – For Third Time Since August

Listen to this article:
0:00
0:00

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • For the third time in just over two months, Barry Hertz used a film review to advance highly critical commentary about Israel.
  • Hertz injected Israel and Gaza into a review of an unrelated Sacha Baron Cohen comedy while failing to acknowledge the substantial expert rejection of “genocide” allegations.
  • Globe and Mail readers themselves criticized the column for offering political lecturing instead of a substantive review of the film.

For the third time in a little over two months, Barry Hertz, The Globe & Mail’s staff film editor and deputy arts editor, has devoted an ostensible film review to propagating anti-Israel talking points instead.

In mid-August and then again on October 1, Hertz reviewed two anti-Israel ‘documentaries’ which alleged serious claims against Jerusalem for its counter-terrorism operations against Palestinian terrorists. In both cases, he took the allegations of filmmakers at face value and failed to apply anything resembling a critical lens against the outlandish allegations that were made.

Israel Shoehorned Into an Unrelated Movie Review

But it was his most recent review, published October 22, which found a most peculiar way to shoehorn Israel into an entirely unrelated conversation, and predictably, only from a specific and highly critical way.

His opinion column, “Who Iz I? movie review: Laugh-free sequel represents a stunning career crash,” reviewed the recent film featuring comedian Sacha Baron Cohen, Ali G: Who Iz I?

While Hertz is certainly entitled to lambaste the film as he sees fit, and criticize the performance of its lead actor, stating that Cohen has “cratered so magnificently” in his comedy, he managed to find multiple occasions throughout the review to fit Israel into the conversation, despite little apparent reason to do so.

Sacha Baron Cohen’s Support for Israel Becomes Part of the Critique

Hertz wrote that “today, there is plenty of chatter that the culture at large has turned against Cohen because of his politics – that the comedian, who has spoken proudly of Israel in the past but said little of the state’s actions in Gaza since Oct. 7, is fit to be thrown into the dustbin of history.”

While such “chatter” undoubtedly exists, this appears to be a bizarre non sequitur for Hertz to include, particularly given that he acknowledges immediately afterwards that “there is little doubt that anti-Zionism, as well as antisemitism” play a role in such rhetoric.

A Comedy Line Is Recast as Commentary on Gaza

But Hertz offered yet more hyper-focused anti-Israel commentary, writing elsewhere that “perhaps the true nadir” of the film was when one of Cohen’s characters, a Mossad agent, makes a joke about genocide, “a line that feels explicitly and callously designed to wave away the current state of affairs in the Middle East.”

Given that the “genocide” slurs against Israel have been repeatedly repudiated and debunked by actual scholars of warfare in a growing consensus (though notably, almost universally ignored by the mainstream Canadian news media), mocking its usage is hardly inappropriate, and certainly not “callous,” as Hertz claimed.

In contrast, to repeat such unfounded slurs is perhaps a far more callous move, given that by no stretch has “genocide” actually taken place, a possibility that Hertz does not acknowledge in his column.

The repeated opportunities by Hertz to lambaste Israel in his opinion column did not go unnoticed by commenters in The Globe and Mail’s website. One commenter asked “is there any chance we could get an actual movie review of the actual movie in question? The above offering is a heavy political commentary,” while another stated “I expect to read a movie review not a political lecturing.”

Comments