Globe Again Grants Hussein Ibish A Soapbox To Blame Israel For Instability While Excusing Hamas Terrorism

September 22, 2025

Hussein Ibish appears to have an axe to grind against Israel, and his title as a “senior resident scholar” at the prestigious-sounding Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington, DC, has made him a darling of the Canadian media, including CBC News and the Globe and Mail. Once platformed, the sky’s the limit: in the past, he’s accused Israel of grabbing land, of war crimes, and of provoking a peaceful Hezbollah through its audacious pager attacks, escalating tensions in the region beyond repair.

Now, he’s back with a recycled version of this last claim: Israel’s strike against senior Hamas officials in Qatar marks it as a wanton aggressor. Israel, to hear Hussein tell it, is prone to flying off the handle, and as a result, hopes for the region are now well and truly lost (again).

In his September 11 opinion column entitled: “Israel’s Qatar bombing didn’t kill its intended targets, but it killed hopes for a Gaza ceasefire,” Ibish laid all his cards on the table: “Few Israelis seem to be aware of their growing reputation… as an out-of-control rogue state that has become a primary source of regional instability and insecurity.”

Here, Ibish has sent cause and effect right out the window. Whatever readers do, he suggested, they should pay no attention to the true destabilizing factors in the region.

Pay no attention Hamas’s 20 years of rocket attacks, terrorism, and hostage-taking, culminating in the massacre of Oct. 7. Forget 20 years of Hezbollah cross-border fire. Ignore Houthi attacks on all Red Sea shipping, including killing workers on non-Israeli ships. Never mind Iran’s escalating nuclear program and proxy militias. Because Ibish mentioned none of these.

Instead, he claimed – it’s right there in the headline – that Israel’s actions killed hopes for peace, rather than Hamas’s repeated sabotage of negotiations. Hamas has rejected offers, raised demands, all while openly vowing to repeat the October 7 attacks “again and again.”

Ibish’s claim that Israel “killed hopes” excuses everything Hamas has done: starve hostages, violate ceasefires, and refuse to disarm.

In reality, there was no serious peace process in place that Israel could have “killed,” even if it had wanted to. Instead, it saw clearly that Hamas would never budge, and that a strike against its leadership, if successful, would be a surer way to peace. This strategy worked with the execution of Hezbollah leader Nasrallah in Lebanon; it could work in Gaza as well.

Most seriously, Ibish accused Israel of regional “destabilization.” As evidence, he mentioned the toppling of Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad in 2024 by local rebels. It’s true that Syria’s regime change probably wouldn’t have happened were it not for Israel’s actions, including neutering Hezbollah, which might otherwise have come to Assad’s aid.

But Syria under Assad was hardly “stable and secure.” It was embroiled in a 13-year civil war. Assad was a dictator who slaughtered hundreds of thousands of his own citizens, empowered Iran and Hezbollah, and invited Russian intervention.

Many analysts actually see clearly that Israel’s actions have probably helped stabilize the region. Israel has limited Hezbollah’s entrenchment and Iran’s expansion. Weakening Hezbollah’s stranglehold over Lebanon could eventually mean sovereignty for Beirut. And Israel has worked for decades to prevent Iranian expansionism across the entire Middle East.

And that’s only on the military front. Israel’s participation in the Abraham Accords created unprecedented ties of business and leisure between Israel and the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and Sudan. Israel also has longstanding peace treaties with Jordan and Egypt, creating the potential for a massive bloc that could stand together to oppose radical Islamist expansionism—with Israel at its hub.

Despite Ibish’s impassioned complaints, Israel isn’t the villain here; it’s the shield standing between Iran’s terror proxies and regional collapse. Blaming Israel for its defensive actions while ignoring Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis, and Tehran is like blaming a firefighter for fire damage.

Ibish has once again leveraged his snazzy title and “prestigious” organization—in reality a shadowy organization criticized for promoting Saudi interests—to point in the wrong direction entirely, in an effort to fool Globe and Mail readers into blaming Israel for everything that’s wrong with the world.

September 22, 2025
September 22, 2025

Comments