Global News Reporter Nathaniel Dove Again Hides Behind A Façade Of Balance, Sanitizing Hamas War Crimes And Omitting UNRWA Terror Ties

Global News host Nathaniel Dove has once again devoted nearly an entire broadcast to unverified claims and anti-Israel narratives — with barely a token nod to Israel’s position. He aired serious accusations without scrutiny, while leaving out key context. The result produced a report that misled Global News viewers more than it informed them.

In the October 22 broadcast, “International court rules Israel must allow UN aid in Gaza” Dove began by dismissing documented evidence of UNRWA employees’ ties to Hamas. Some even participated in the October 7, 2023 massacre, which the UN openly admits. Multiple countries (e.g. the U.S., Canada, and others) suspended funding after these revelations, yet the International Court of Justice (ICJ)—part of the UN—announced that “Israel has not substantiated its allegations that a significant part of UNRWA employees ‘are members of Hamas… or other terrorist factions.’”

Click below to watch the segment:

In fact, Israel presented the ICJ with names of 100 terror operatives on UNRWA’s payroll, plus intelligence suggesting that over 2,135 UNRWA employees were members of Hamas or Islamic Jihad. Over 30 UNRWA facilities have been found to contain terrorist infrastructure like tunnel shafts. And, of course, a Hamas server farm was located directly under—and connected to—UNRWA’s Gaza headquarters.

For the ICJ to determine that this doesn’t represent a “significant portion” of UNRWA activities is ludicrous. But its bias in supporting UNRWA’s continuation in Gaza has been clear for a while.

While Dove held Israel to the high standard of having to “substantiate” its claims, he dropped the bar when it came to the Palestinian narrative. He tossed in a video clip of a Palestinian man, explaining that Gazans are experiencing “new anguish” even after the ceasefire. Dove summarized the man’s Arabic comments: “This man says his cousin’s body, held by Israel, was so badly tortured they couldn’t identify him.”

Dove could have pointed out that the man’s claims, similarly, had not been “substantiated.” Instead, he aired this egregious allegation without any verification.

To Dove’s credit, he did include a brief video clip from an Israeli spokesperson. She stressed that “Israel adheres to all international law when it comes to any actions inside of the Gaza Strip.”

Yet Dove aired this without comment, making it feel more like an exercise in journalistic box-checking. He also tacked on, at the end of his report, a mention that Hamas was still holding deceased hostages, in violation of the ceasefire agreement.

But mentioning this so casually, in passing, with sterile phrasing like “violating the deal,” ultimately served to downplay Hamas’s war crimes, which have included hostage-taking, torture, and body desecration. This whitewashing is part of an ongoing pattern of reporting from Dove, in which he sanitizes Hamas atrocities while taking a harsh moralistic tone towards Israel.

Throughout his report, Dove surrounded Israel’s perspective with skepticism, stripped of any security context or background about October 7’s brutal Hamas attacks, while launching accusations freely and without challenge.

Even the title of Dove’s report suggests that Israel has systematically been blocking aid to Gaza. At no point does he mention the lengths to which Israel has gone throughout the war to facilitate aid entry and to work hand-in-hand with organizations like the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. He also made no effort to explain the dangers of delivering aid now that the IDF has pulled out of many areas.

At a time when North American viewers are bombarded with mixed messages as to whether aid is entering Gaza at all, whether crossings are open, and what’s happening to aid once it enters Gaza, Dove’s reporting has done little to shed light.

By including one Israeli spokesperson, Dove’s reporting may seem balanced, but it consistently fails the test of substance. Global News has once again misinformed its viewers by airing unverified claims, downplaying Hamas crimes, and omitting crucial context about aid and security realities.

Comments