A recent CTV News report by Kamil Karamali turned a Gaza flotilla activist’s allegations against Israel into a soft-focus victim story with virtually no journalistic scrutiny.
In the May 25 report, “Gaza flotilla members captured by Israeli military report sexual violence,” Karamali told viewers that Shahid Mahmoud, a Belleville activist, had been “taken captive by Israeli soldiers.” He then allowed Mahmoud to make lurid claims against Israel, including sexual violence, all while framing the flotilla as a peaceful aid mission.
Watch the full segment below:
Karamali introduced Mahmoud as one of more than 400 participants in the Global Sumud Flotilla, “trying to carry aid to Gaza before Israeli forces captured them.” What Karamali didn’t say was that the “aid” carried by this and other flotillas is purely “symbolic,” even according to organizers.
These flotillas are PR campaigns, not serious relief operations. They cost millions of dollars in donations and activist funding. If the goal were aid, activists could buy food, medicine, baby formula, and other supplies, and have them delivered easily via one of 600 aid trucks entering Gaza daily.
Instead, flotilla anarchists pour huge sums into boats, travel, legal support, and publicity, all to stage a confrontation with Israel. Karamali never called out or explained this primary purpose of the flotilla.
In our view, Karamali’s approach was deceptive from the start. He opened his segment by announcing that Mahmoud was “taken captive by Israeli soldiers.” He later repeated that Israeli forces had “captured” the flotilla participants, with no mention of why.
Mahmoud wasn’t sitting quietly at home when Israeli soldiers dragged him away. He was part of a flotilla trying to breach Israel’s lawful naval blockade. The blockade, imposed after years of weapons smuggling, blocks maritime access to Hamas-controlled Gaza to ensure weapons and other contraband cannot enter.
Mahmoud and his fellow activists deliberately sailed into a confrontation. Having seen previous flotilla participants sent home unharmed, he presumably expected little personal danger.
Travelling to the Mediterranean willingly with the goal of confronting the IDF, Mahmoud is hardly an innocent victim. Yet Karamali’s report, in our estimation, took every opportunity to make him seem as sympathetic as possible.
That included not mentioning that Mahmoud is actually an organizer with Belleville for Justice and Peace. That group hosted a Gaza event last year with Yipeng Ge, an Ottawa physician known for his post-October 7 torrent of hate speech on X, including open glorification of Hamas terrorism.
Sharing Mahmoud’s background would have helped viewers understand his motivations.
Instead, Karamali let Mahmoud claim, with no evidence, that participants reported “sexual violence.” That included “humiliating strip searches, sexual taunting, groping, and pulling of genitals, and multiple accounts of rape.”
Karamali then spoke to Canadian activist Ehab Lotayef who claimed that an Israeli soldier beat him and stabbed him. Karamali only briefly mentioned that Israel denied allegations of mistreatment, and then returned to Mahmoud’s emotional testimony.
And as brutal as Mahmoud said the experience was, he also told Karamali he’d return to the Mediterranean “in a heartbeat.”
From our vantage point, Karamali’s history of one-sided anti-Israel reporting makes his softball approach seem less like careless journalism and more like advocacy. He has repeatedly used his platform at CTV to stack segments with anti-Israel voices, omit extremist backgrounds to make subjects more sympathetic, and repeat pro-Palestinian talking points with no opposing view.
Here, too, he presented explosive allegations with none of the legwork to back them up. He ignored the bigger geopolitical picture while relying on emotional storytelling that tilts the scale heavily toward one side yet again.






