Listening to Michael Lynk, former UN Special Rapporteur “for Human Rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territory” being interviewed on CTV as part of Your Morning on July 11, one could be forgiven for thinking that Israel had gone to war to wantonly cause damage to Gaza. He created this picture – untethered to reality – principally by deleting Hamas from the picture.
CTV News’ anchor stated that “Israel’s Defense Minister is directing the IDF to eventually relocate all of Gaza’s remaining population, that’s millions of people, into a new, what they’re describing as Humanitarian City in (the Gazan region of) Rafah, and that’s what Rafah looks like right now,” and showed viewers an image of damaged buildings in Gaza.
She continued by asking her guest, “most of Rafah has been leveled, there’s barely any sanitation, we know that there’s a limit to food, it is described as a humanitarian city by some, it is described as a concentration camp by others, what would it actually look like and what would it actually be?”
There was not an iota of context in sight.
Left unsaid was that there is a war going on – it started when Hamas led the inhumane massacre and hostage taking on October 7, 2023. Hamas saw it as merely the opening salvo: their ultimate intention is to wipe Israel off the map.
Israel was forced into a war of self-defence against a group that had spent literally decades weaponizing virtually every square inch of Gaza and converting it into a giant hub of terrorism.
While showing the destruction in Rafah, CTV neglected to mention that Israel’s actions in Rafah have been to significantly downgrade the terror threat embedded there, including tunnels used to import weapons, stored weapons, and numerous terrorists including ex-leader Yayha Sinwar. Given Hamas’ enormous network of tunnels used to store weapons, terrorists and even hostages, of which the entrances and exits were typically in civilian buildings, to destroy these tunnels necessitated destroying their above-ground portals.
While conditions in a war zone may be challenging, it is bizarre to mention the food situation without mentioning that Israel, together with the United States, has established the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) to address the provision of aid to Gazans without having it looted by Hamas. Despite bounties being placed on the heads of GHF aid workers by Palestinian terrorists, and with Hamas murdering more than 12 humanitarians, the GHF has provided 66 million meals to Gazans in just over a month, and continues to do so.
When looking for clarity about the concept of a humanitarian city in Rafah, CTV News turned to Michael Lynk.
Lynk has a long history of acting as an anti-Israel propagandist, having even claimed, according to NGO Monitor, that “terror groups Hamas and Hezbollah pose no real threat to Israel.”
Ethics of balanced reporting would dictate that CTV include a diversity of voices. Instead, CTV provided Lynk with an open platform and with no balance offered.
In his comments, Lynk said that “Haaretz, which is the leading Israeli daily newspaper, has said that Israel’s efforts is to build the most moral concentration camp in the world, with tongue in cheek, and elsewhere in their editorial they said the only purpose of this ongoing war is to encourage Palestinians to leave.”
It is difficult to call Haaretz “the leading Israeli daily newspaper.” Haaretz hosts extreme left-wing views and has a marginal readership in Israel. Israel is proposing investing billions of dollars and up to a year to build this city where Gazans could live, separated from Hamas’ terrorist influence.
Additionally, the whole concept appears out of date, as Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has, according to media reports, told officials to find alternative plans.
Lynk continued by saying that “Gaza has become a 21st version of what Dresden or Berlin looked like at the end of the Second World War, hardly any food is getting in, no fuel for the last 130 days the UN reports, so hospitals are running out of fuel to perform even the most basic of services, water is extremely scarce, none of the attributes we need for viable human life is now present in Gaza.”
Dresden and Berlin are interesting points of comparison. Under Nazi Germany, they were cities ruined by a war their country started, yet this does not make them the victims.
It is interesting to note that social media accounts from Gaza show an operational falafel store in Gaza City, a family baking a birthday cake, and gift packages of edible treats for sale. Lynk’s version of events is not the full picture, and not by a long shot.
Yet CTV News presented it like it is and their coverage only served to mislead their viewers.






