CP24 Broadcast Rewrites History, Paints Palestinians As Victims Of 1948 War, Ignoring They Sought To Exterminate Israel

In 1947, when the United Nations proposed to split the British Mandate of Palestine (whose legal title had already been formally recognized as being set to reconstitute a Jewish homeland), dividing up the territory and awarding the majority of it for an Arab state, it was nevertheless rejected by Arab parties but accepted by Jewish representatives.

When Israel later declared independence, it was attacked by seven neighbouring Arab armies, whose leaders made no secret of their attempt to commit genocide against the newly reborn Jewish country, with figures such as Jamal al-Husseini, Foreign Minister of the All-Palestine Government, promising that “the blood will flow like rivers in the Middle East.”

Following that attempted genocide against Israel, pro-Palestinian activists have since mourned Israel’s existence and the failure of their effort to exterminate the country, terming it the “Nakba,” Arabic for catastrophe.

While the continued hateful rejection of Israel’s right to exist remains widespread in Palestinian society, CP24 recently provided viewers with a highly sanitized update on their mourning.

The May 12 broadcast featured the host telling viewers that Palestinians were marking the 78th anniversary of the “mass expulsion from land that makes up modern-day Israel.”

Watch the full clip below:

This is a strongly misleading retelling of events on the part of CP24. In actuality, many – if not most – of the Arabs who left Israel upon its independence in 1948 did so, not because they were forcibly expelled, as the broadcast claimed, but because they were being strongly pressured to do so by Arab leaders.

These Arab leaders, convinced that a victory over the nascent Jewish State was inevitable, warned Arabs to leave the area so that the Jews could be more easily annihilated and so that they would not be caught in the crossfire. After the anticipated genocide of the Jews was complete, they could return.

But when that plan failed to materialize, rather than accepting that Israel was not going to be willingly destroyed, the ‘Nakba’ campaign became an annual event, uncritically repeated by much of the news media.

However, the very concept of the Nakba is deeply problematic. In addition to representing a fundamental rejection of Israel’s right to exist in its ancestral homeland, it is an effort to portray those who sought to carry out the genocide of the Jews as the victims, rather than the perpetrators of an attempted mass extermination.

The Nakba industry, commemorated every year in an effort to paint Israel as the villain of the Middle East, is enabled by news media outlets like CP24 who, rather than point out that the Palestinian-Arabs were architects of the 1948 War of Independence after rejecting a state of their own, simply airbrushed this history from mention.

As one commentator pointed out, “Arabs having a Nakba day is like Germans having a day of mourning for losing WWII. Palestinians are the only people on the planet whom the world provides a safety net so they could amble from one defeat to the next without learning anything.”

If CP24 wants to report on Palestinian commemorations for the so-called ‘Nakba,’ then they are free to do so, but it should not be at the expense of factual accuracy and informing Canadians that the Palestinian-Arabs in 1948 willingly embraced the very circumstances to which they now lament.

Comments