Concordia University Student Newspaper Marks 3 Years Of October 7 By Spreading Anti-Israel Slurs

Listen to this article:
0:00
0:00

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • The Link erased the cause of the Gaza war: Its October 7 anniversary editorial condemned Israel without meaningfully acknowledging the Hamas-led massacres that triggered the conflict.
  • History and Zionism were seriously distorted: The editorial omitted the Arab rejection of Israel and subsequent war while presenting an unsupported caricature of Zionism.
  • The “genocide” allegation was treated as credible without serious scrutiny: The Link cited a controversial UN commission while excluding the legal and military experts who have rejected the accusation.

To mark the third anniversary of the Palestinian terrorist massacres of October 7, 2023, the Concordia University campus newspaper The Link penned a rambling anti-Israel screed which accused Israel of virtually every crime under the sun and somehow did not even mention what actually took place three years earlier.

October 7 Erased From an Editorial Published on Its Anniversary

The editorial “Three years of genocide, decades of occupation” began by writing that “since Oct. 7, 2023, 73,470 Palestinians have been killed,” without bothering to acknowledge what precisely happened on October 7 (namely, the massacres by thousands of Palestinian terrorists against Israelis) to actually start the war in the first place, akin to writing an article about the supposed evils of the Allied forces in fighting Nazi Germany, while omitting any mention of Hitler’s invasion of Poland.

Beyond citing unproven Hamas-provided casualty claims, and making zero distinction between civilians and combatants, the editorial then told readers that it was “78 years since the Nakba—meaning catastrophe in Arabic—which led to the forced displacement of over 700,000 Palestinians from their homes in the conflict that eventually formed the State of Israel.”

Once again, the devil is in the details, left entirely unsaid by The Link. The so-called “nakba” began when Israel’s Arab neighbours (and Arabs inside Israel) refused to accept the Jewish State’s independence, and insisted on launching an attempted war of annihilation against it instead, and creating a number of consequences, including refugees.

Had the Arabs succeeded, it would have undoubtedly been a mass genocide of Jews in Israel, and thus, the “nakba” was a victory over an openly-genocidal attempt at another Holocaust.

Elsewhere, the editorial’s author takes aim at Zionism, claiming without evidence that “Even Zionism changes definitions depending on the speaker. To some, it means that the Jewish people deserve a homeland; to others, it means the state of Israel is operating without consequence.”

Zionism is widely seen as the Jewish People’s national liberation movement; the right to self-determination in their ancestral lands, and it is unclear whether any legitimate voice has ever argued that Zionism means Israel can operate “without consequence.” But that did not stop The Link from presenting it anyway.

Conveniently, The Link fails to actually provide a single example of any self-described Zionist who ascribes to that definition, raising serious questions about whether this is anything more than a straw man logical fallacy, meaning a deliberate misrepresentation of one’s opponent’s views.

The “Genocide” Slur Repeated Without Proof

As with so many other similar commentaries over the last three years, the editorial repeatedly levels the “genocide” slur against Israel, all without ever actually proving it. Instead, it cites the United Nations Commission of Inquiry (COI) as having made that claim, though it did not mention the highly controversial nature of the commission’s members.

More importantly, scores of legal experts and military scholars have thoroughly rejected the genocide claims against Israel, though these voices have been almost universally ignored in the Canadian news media.

Anti-Israel Activism Presented as Campus Journalism

The Link is not simply another newspaper; it is a publication located at Concordia University, a school with tens of thousands of students, and has a long track record of regurgitating anti-Israel narratives and framing it as news.

The Link claims that it “pledges to report with full accuracy, avoiding misinformation and disinformation.” Can The Link seriously claim that this editorial comes anywhere close to that standard?

Comments