Columnist Geoffrey P. Johnston Uncritically Repeats Claims Made By Gaza Flotilla Activists

The recent flotilla to Gaza, where a group of activists set sail in a highly-publicized spectacle, was framed by its supporters as a humanitarian endeavour seeking to bring aid to Gaza. However, in reality, organizers admitted that the effort was primarily a PR stunt, and Israel says virtually no aid was found on board.

However, in his May 28 opinion column “Flotilla controversy exposes ‘double standard,’” Geoffrey P. Johnston appears to accept the unfounded claims of flotilla organizers hook, line and sinker.

His article was published in The Kingston Whig-Standard,  The County Weekly News, The Cornwall Standard-Freeholder, and a number of other publications in Eastern Ontario.

Johnston begins by claiming that “the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza garners precious little international attention.” It is unclear what kind of “attention” Johnston has in mind that Gaza somehow lacks, but in Canada, Gaza continues to be promoted across the Canadian news media, by federal government officials, ‘humanitarian’ groups and others, even as footage from Gaza shows that the supposed crisis somehow includes upscale restaurants, bakeries and shopping malls.

In fact, the flotilla stunt is a perfect example of this practice, with scores of news media outlets publishing and broadcasting sympathetic reports about activists, rarely offering any meaningful challenge or context, and instead portraying them as humanitarians rather than anti-Israel activists.

Johnston refers to “Israel’s rough treatment of Western activists attempting to deliver aid” to Gaza, appearing to take at face value that the activists were “attempting to deliver aid,” and making no mention of Israel’s statement that they were bringing virtually no aid. He also overlooked the towering detail that Israel sends in some 600 trucks into Gaza every single day, and that if these activists wanted to assist those efforts, they could have done so.

As for Israel’s supposedly “rough treatment,” despite a highly-publicized video of an Israeli minister mocking the activists – a video widely condemned by Israeli officials – there is no actual evidence of abuse, unlike in Spain, where videos show Spanish police savagely beating flotilla activists, a detail that went unmentioned by Johnston.

Johnston’s article relies largely on an assortment of quotes, primarily from critics of Israel, largely depicting Jerusalem as the culprit behind Gaza’s supposedly poor humanitarian conditions. He writes that “UN News reported that there have been 22 attacks on health facilities in Gaza this year.”

However, Johnston does not note that many of these health facilities in Gaza have been used and thus converted into military facilities by Palestinian terrorist groups. In one notable instance earlier in 2026, Doctors Without Borders (MSF), a group that has been a regular detractor of Israel, admitted the presence of armed Palestinian terrorists in Nasser Hospital, Gaza’s largest health complex, even going so far as to suspend working at the location as a result. Yet this detail was nowhere to be seen in Johnston’s commentary.

Johnston ends his column by proclaiming that “human rights are universal and must be applied equally to everyone, including Palestinians in Gaza and Western activists attempting to deliver aid to those in desperate need.”

Rather than simply accepting defenses made by flotilla activists that they were trying to “deliver aid,” Johnston should have reminded readers of the paucity of aid on board these craft, that their leadership admitted the stunt nature of the campaign, and that an enormous amount of aid already enters Gaza every day. By failing to note these facts, Johnston permitted his column to effectively become a press release for flotilla activists.

Comments