The Big Story podcast, produced by CityNews, promises that it offers “an in-depth look at the issues, culture and personalities shaping Canada today.” But two recent episodes show instead a narrow fixation on Israel, with a very specific lens.
The September 23 episode entitled: “A life-risking trip to deliver aid to Gaza: an Ontario woman shares her story,” hosted by Caryn Ceolin, featured an interview with Zaheera Soomar, a member of the anti-Israel flotilla parade to Gaza.
Listen to the full episode below:
Soomar has a checkered history as an anti-Israel extremist. Canary Mission has criticized Soomar claiming she: 1) posed as a Jew in a failed attempt to sneak into a Toronto synagogue during an event there in 2024, 2) has reportedly denied Hamas’ October 7 atrocities, 3) spread antisemitism and 4) expressed support for terrorists. Ceolin didn’t share this with her listeners. Instead, Soomar was presented as a “Toronto-based, pro-Palestinian activist.”
The flotilla, officially claiming it is offering aid to Gaza, did no such thing. Israel has said the Sumud flotilla is directly backed by Hamas. Additionally, The Freedom Flotilla Coalition, listed as a supporter, includes the IHH as a member, which has links to Hamas.
Soomar said that Canada “hasn’t stopped the genocide and it hasn’t stopped the man-made famine,” Ceolin did not explain that the UK’s Foreign Secretary, the US and Germany have all denied a genocide is taking place. She likewise didn’t address the continued existence of Gaza’s 2 million inhabitants after two years of ‘genocide’.
Israel has multiple humanitarian operations to assist Gazan civilians. Israel has allowed over two million tonnes of aid into Gaza. It has co-founded the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, who have delivered over 176 million meals. They have purchased tents, facilitated children’s Polio vaccinations, and repaired water pipelines. 4,000 people have been repatriated for medical care.
What Ceolin didn’t explain is that Hamas’ stealing and reselling of aid at inflated prices, as well as terrorizing Gazans who want to collect aid from the GHF as well as GHF workers, has deprived many Gazans of the aid Israel is facilitating.
Soomar did admit that the Sumud flotilla is likely to turn into a PR stunt, “if we get intercepted or stopped, or bombed or attacked by Israel. Number one, it’s going to show the world what Israel is doing and how it’s blocking humanitarian aid. And number two, it just creates a general awareness of what truly is happening in Gaza at the moment.”
If the flotilla participants genuinely wanted to send humanitarian aid to Gaza, they could send it via experienced humanitarian organizations. It is hard to believe that any country would allow foreign, antagonistic boats to approach shores they control and dump their contents on its beaches without any interception or checks. Yet Ceolin can almost be heard nodding along to Soomar’s narrative.
Two days later, on September 25, “Carney recognizes a Palestinian statehood.. now what?”, host Cormac MacSweeney spoke with Colin Robertson, a former Canadian diplomat, and discussed Ottawa’s recent recognition of a Palestinian state.
Listen to the full episode below:
Framing Israel as the hostile actor, MacSweeney asked his guest, “So can you even have a two-state solution here? Can that be accomplished when one side is saying a flatout no?”
Israel has offered the Arabs a two-state solution seven times. Each time the Arabs gave a resounding no, underlined by their refusal to recognize Israel. In 2005 Israel once again attempted the formula ‘land for peace,’ giving Gaza to the Arabs to rule independently. In response, they elected Hamas and built a terrorist tunnel infrastructure there. Given this context, which country would like to give their genocidal neighbours yet more land for them to attack Israel from? Yet Israel was repeatedly blamed on this episode for the lack of peace in the region.
Robertson bemoaned that “the annexation policies that Israel is following in violation of international law.” But what he considered settled law is far from it. Expert Eugene Kontorovich, has stated explicitly that “Israeli settlements in the West Bank do not violate international law.”
Robertson further stated that Israel is “continuing its rampage through Gaza.” This allegation ignores both Israel’s necessity to defend itself against a genocidal Islamic terrorist group seeking its destruction, and the efforts it has taken to protect civilians in Gaza.
Despite MacSweeney asking some probing questions and Robertson’s acknowledgement of Hamas as a terror organization, MacSweeney’s podcast laid the blame at Israel without sharing the context or opposing views.
In its two recent podcasts, CityNews has continued its biased reporting on the Hamas-Israel war, presenting an anti-Israel extremist without challenge in one episode, and in the other, offering the public a deeply distorted picture, all without balance.






