CityNews Broadcast Spreads Baseless Famine Claims In Gaza, Ignores All Relevant Facts

July 21, 2025

Erica Natividad’s July 15 City News broadcast entitled: “Hunger Crisis in Gaza Deepens,” painted the food situation in Gaza as dire.

Watch the full segment below:

She opened her broadcast to the distressing optics of Gazans clamoring for soup at a soup kitchen. Some of the aid entering Gaza – thousands of pallets in fact – have entered the territory and are awaiting distribution by humanitarian agencies who have yet to pick it up. Additionally, COGAT (Israel’s body coordinating aid in Gaza) stated on July 14 that over the past few weeks “more than 7,500 tons of flour for bakeries and over 3,600 tons of food for community kitchens including legumes, pasta, hummus, preserved meat and chicken and more, entered Gaza through the complementary aid mechanism operated by UN agencies and international organizations.”

Yet Natividad said: “at least half a million people in the Gaza Strip face starvation according to an analysis released in May by the World Health Organization. It added that the enclave faces a high risk of famine occurring by the end of September.” It is as if relevant data simply didn’t matter at all.

Famine predictions in Gaza are two-a-penny. Yet, thankfully, despite their frequency and gravitas, famine has failed to materialize. COGAT noted the May prediction did not take into account the significant 339,000 tonnes of food aid that entered Gaza during the ceasefire. Israel’s Foreign Ministry said that the forecast was “based on biased data – sourced from Hamas’s ‘Ministry of Health,’” which it said was “known for spreading propaganda”.

Natividad bemoaned the fact that “UNRWA, the UN relief and works agency, is still banned from bringing in aid.” Bizarrely, she didn’t mention why. UNRWA workers were found to have been directly involved in the October 7, 2023 massacres, and that a Hamas command centre was found directly underneath the agency’s Gaza headquarters.

She continued: “Israel and the United States have set up the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which uses private US firms to transport aid to distribution hubs, which the UN refuses to work with. On Tuesday, the UN [human] rights office claimed that hundreds of killings have occurred near these hubs within the past 6 weeks alone, citing data from various aid organizations.”

Strangely, Natividad did not include that the GHF has delivered an incredible 76 million meals in its short existence thus far As for the alleged killings, Natividad did say that “The GHF has repeatedly denied that incidents have occurred on its sites and instead accused the UN of misinformation, which the UN denies.”

She didn’t share a recent report that, according to the New York Post, “found that within days of the first meal deliveries, GHF became the target of ‘a deliberate narrative assault, driven less by verifiable facts than the demands of a competing narrative,’ that relied on terror group Hamas for information and was uncritically printed by US and European media outlets.”

Natividad also mentions that: “UNRWA also revealed more disturbing data Tuesday, saying that one in ten children screened in clinics run by the agency in Gaza since January of last year were malnourished. They claimed that before this war, acute malnutrition was rarely seen in the Gaza Strip.”

While this sounds terrible, it is worth noting that in February, the UK Lawyers for Israel organization conducted a review of famine and severe malnutrition allegations. Among other things, it found that levels of malnutrition were not materially higher than before the war. One of the reasons for the misinformation around malnutrition in Gaza was due to “using an incorrect baseline figure for pre-war acute malnutrition, which made it appear that there had been a sharp increase in the phenomenon during the war.”

When discussing the food situation in Gaza, Natividad did not provide sufficient context and balance. She omitted crucial information that would help her viewers fully understand and learn about the events in the Middle East comprehensively, not just from one narrow view detached from the facts.

Comments