CBC continues to promote hardline pro-Palestinian propaganda, courtesy of the ever-generous Canadian taxpayer.
In the April 16 episode of Ideas, host Nahlah Ayed – who has a long history of aggressively anti-Israel broadcasting – interviewed Daniel Levy, an Israeli commentator who has been accused of promoting fringe and “kooky” proposals that have minimal support by either Israelis or Palestinians.
The episode was produced by Naheed Mustafa, whose X (Twitter) page features scores of extremist anti-Israel posts.


Nevertheless, Levy was given an hourlong platform by Ayed to spew anti-Israel diatribes under the guise of being an intellectual discussion about the state of the Middle East, while Ayed refused to provide anything even vaguely resembling balance or intellectual rigour.
The segment “Is the two-state solution dead?” began with Levy attempting to depict Israel as a cruel master of post-ceasefire Gaza, saying that “even tents have not been allowed in during the winter, tent poles being considered as a dual use item and therefore strictly prohibited under the absolute control that Israel still maintained in the Gaza perimeter.”
Listen to the full segment below:
Levy’s comments were characteristic of much of his rhetoric during the interview. While superficially true, it ignores important details that he avoided mentioning. While it is true some tent poles are ‘dual use’ (i.e. potentially used for Hamas weapons), nearly 700,000 tents were permitted into Gaza during the winter, a rather large detail ignored.
He continued by depicting Gaza as something of a hellscape, saying there was a “collapsing of the entirety of the infrastructure” there, despite footage and photos from Gazans there showing very much the opposite.
He said that in Gaza, “Palestinians are still killed every day…so the idea that this is a ceasefire is in of itself, incorrect.” Ignoring that there have been scores of Palestinian attacks and attempted attacks on Israel during this same period, while focusing exclusively on Israeli counter-terrorism operations, Levy drew a picture of how he would spend most of the interview.
Levy next began talking about what he would spend much of the interview repeating, when he referred to “the nakba, in what’s known as the catastrophe, in the expulsion of Palestinians on Israel’s creation.”
Once again, Levy’s characterization is a mishmash of truth and highly misleading statements.
While some Arabs were forcibly expelled by Israel, many others left directly at the behest of Arab leaders.
In 1948, upon Israel’s rebirth, the Jewish State was attacked by its Arab neighbors, who sought to annihilate the country. Arab leaders expected a quick victory over Israel, and many encouraged their compatriots to leave the Jewish State so they would not be caught in the crossfire, and expecting that they could return in short order, following the presumed genocide of Jews.
However, Levy made zero mention of the broader context of Israel’s War of Independence, utterly ignored the attempts by Arab states to invade and destroy Israel, and censored out any acknowledgement that Arab leaders played a central role in the suffering that many of their peers endured.
Levy continued his largely uninterrupted rant by telling Ayed and listeners that Israel wants Gaza to not “be livable for Palestinians.” Yet again, he hid from view the most central crux of the conflict, namely that Hamas, the openly genocidal Islamic terrorist group in Gaza, continues to see the destruction of Israel as its solemn religious obligation. Israel has demanded Hamas’ disarming, which it has rejected.
Though Levy conveniently ignored this elephant in the room, any credible journalist or interviewer should have pressed him on his erasure of the murderous threat posed by Hamas and other regional Islamic terrorist groups. Of course, she did no such thing.
He soon turned his attention to the “Jewish settler population,” framing their presence in their historic and ancestral homeland as a direct obstacle to peace (later spreading the “greater Israel” falsehood, claiming that Israel wanted to grow its territory, and saying that in Israel, there is an “inability to accept the idea of Palestinian sovereign statehood.”)
Levy could have explored why subsequent Israeli governments – and increasingly, the Israeli public at large – sees a Palestinian state on its doorstep as an existential danger, given the widespread refusal of Palestinian society to accept Israel’s very right to exist, and the ongoing glorification of terrorism by the Palestinian Authority (PA). But continuing with his narrative of Israel being the obstacle to peace, he instead quoted Palestinian-American professor Rashid Khalidi who claimed that Israel is simply a “settler colony,” an ignorant inversion of history which erases three thousand years of Jewish presence in the land.
Predictably, Levy leveled the false “genocide” slur at Israel, saying that Israeli “society has coalesced around a willingness to pursue a genocide.” Despite making such a scandalous claim, and not even deigning to offer evidence, Ayed said nothing. But there is no genocide in Gaza, but a counter-terrorism operation against an openly genocidal Palestinian terrorist movement seeking the annihilation of Israel. Moreover, Israel took more steps to avoid civilian casualties than any other military in modern history, even as Palestinians actively used their own people as human shields.
As the (largely one-sided) conversation continued, Levy appeared eager to prove his anti-Israel bona fides, characterizing Israel as “a regime of Jewish supremacy” and claiming without evidence that Israel was “not really being inclusive when it came to the non-Jewish citizenry of Israel.”
This is brazenly false. Israel’s Arab minorities enjoy full and equal democratic rights under the law, a reality that is likely unknown to most listeners.
The interview was notable not just for what Levy said, but what he glossed over, including the epoch-defining October 7, 2023 massacres, which he said were “a shock,” without elaborating about the bestial murders by Hamas, nor the direct role it had in causing regional instability.
At another point, he complained that UNRWA, the disgraced United Nations agency which has been accused of extensive ties to Palestinian terrorism and whose staff took part in the October 7 massacres, was banned by the Israeli government. Neither Levy nor Ayed thought to mention anything about UNRWA’s scandalous history or activities, including the Hamas members who were UNRWA employees, the Hamas command centre under UNRWA’s headquarters in Gaza, its hateful textbooks for Palestinian schoolchildren, and more.
He casually accused Israel of apartheid, citing “international human rights organizations” like Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and others, without actually defending their claims. But these groups – whose fixation on Israel and disinterest in actual human rights abuses has been well documented – cannot be called credible observers of the Middle East in any sense. Their claims of ‘apartheid’ ignore that Israel has willingly offered the Palestinians land of their own, only to have it rejected, and that Israel’s security measures are aimed at protecting Israelis from murderous acts of Palestinian terrorism.
Levy made the astounding claim that Israel is becoming a “nondemocracy,” a point repeatedly reminded to listeners by Ayed. He claimed that Israel was not “being inclusive” to its minority populations, though they enjoy all the same civil and democratic rights as their Jewish peers, a fact ignored.
He complained about Palestinian prisoners being held by Israel, saying they were “being held in detention,” though he opted not to share that they were held after being convicted for their involvement in violence or terrorism, unlike Israeli hostages, held only for their nationality.
Again and again, Levy fixed his gaze almost exclusively at Israel, at one point seeming to recognize the absurdity in his own position, saying that “I don’t want to deny Palestinian agency,” but that is precisely how he devoted the better part of an hour: to describing Israel as a villainous oppressor of Palestinians, while Palestinians were simply innocent victims, apparently helpless to do anything for themselves.
At this juncture, Ayed chimed in, but rather than challenging him for effectively espousing what observer Michael Gerson has called the world’s “soft bigotry of low expectations,” namely giving Palestinians a pass while exclusively blaming Israel, but instead emphasizing what she called the “power asymmetry between Israel and the Palestinians.”
Despite Levy’s claims that “as the most powerful party, it was really in Israel’s hands to decide what direction this took,” Jerusalem has repeatedly offered its hand in peace to the Palestinians, only for it to be bitten in response. Most notably in 2000, Israel offered the Palestinians all of Gaza, virtually all of Judea & Samaria (“West Bank”), and even eastern Jerusalem, giving the Palestinians what their leadership had long claimed they wanted.
The offer was rejected, and the Palestinians engaged in a lengthy campaign of violence and terrorism in response. Levy hid this entire episode from public view, despite it arguably characterizing much of the Israeli-Palestinian experience.
Five years later, Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza, leaving zero Israelis there. But rather than buying peace, it was soon taken over by Hamas, who turned it into a launching pad for terrorism against Israel. This too, was erased by Levy.
As the interview wrapped up, Levy made his position clear, complaining that as long as the world continued to trade with Israel and allow Israelis to participate in sports and song tournaments, it provided Israel “impunity,” in a thinly-veiled call for countries to sanction the Jewish State.
Lacking even a modicum of self-awareness, Levy railed that “Israel is held to no standards, held to a lower standard” than the world. In reality, Israel is held to a standard that is not only higher than the Palestinians, but in the words of journalist Douglas Murray, held to a standard to which nobody would hold themselves. Israel is told it can fight terrorists, but condemned when it does so, and expected to fight in a way that is effectively impossible.
Even amidst the unrepentant anti-Israel propaganda that characterizes most of CBC’s coverage of the Middle East, Nahlah Ayed is among the most aggressive proponents of hardline anti-Israel coverage, and in her April 16 episode, she decided to speak to a marginal and hostile voice for his opinions, continuing the CBC practice of promoting Israeli views primarily only when they express hostility to the Jewish State.
In the face of this relentless one-hour circus of Israel-hate, will CBC’s Ideas program produce a similar one-hour segment unpacking Palestinian propaganda? Don’t count on it.






