CBC’s Front Burner Pushes A Skewed Narrative On Israel’s Nuclear Policy While Simultaneously Downplaying Iran’s Threats

On May 21, CBC’s Front Burner podcast, hosted by Jayme Poisson, released an episode on “Israel’s open nuclear secret,” that saw Poisson interview author Avner Cohen.

Listen to the full segment below:

What fuelled the discussion was, as Poisson elaborated, the “remarkable request” – a dramatic assessment that frames the request not as policy but rather as a gallant, moral imperative – sent to the Trump administration by 30 Democratic lawmakers requesting to have the US government acknowledge that Israel has nuclear weapons.

For a podcast under the CBC, this episode falls under the purview of the broadcaster’s journalistic standards of balance, fairness, and accuracy. Importantly, any engagement in a matter as charged, complex and clouded as the mysterious relationship between Israel and nuclear power is not problematic by default. But a few key things from this episode of Front Burner, and how the complex issue was approached and discussed, demonstrates how this particular episode falls in line with the show’s demonstrated patterns of imbalance and inflammatory coverage of matters related to Israel.

Cohen clarified at the front end of the episode that yes, the discourse around Israel’s possible secretive nuclear activities is not removed from the regional reality the state of Israel is facing, historically and contemporarily: “A big Arab world hostile” to the state and not going anywhere,  and a conflict that is “long term, not easily… resolved.” The reality Israel faces, especially in relation to the Islamic Republic of Iran, is acknowledged by both the host and guest; moving forward, though, the episode doesn’t explore how this key security problem shapes Israel’s actions.

According to Cohen, Israel’s doctrine of opacity in relation to nuclear power is framed as crucial to its self-image and position in the region, arguing it is grounds for hypocrisy when considered alongside recent developments with the Islamic Republic of Iran.

Along these lines, a notable equivalency is made by Poisson: “looking at the region right now, Iran has long framed its need for nuclear weapons as an existential matter for national security. Do you see an ironic resemblance between Israel’s logic in the 1960s and Iran’s logic today?”

This question implicitly frames Israel’s historical logic as comparable to Iran’s current (and really, historical, too) rhetoric, without acknowledging that the regime’s rhetoric includes explicit calls for Israel’s destruction.

Cohen does not address Poisson’s label of “ironic,” but he addresses the exceptionalism of Israel’s supposed nuclear position, and opines that the Islamic Regime is trying “to imitate Israel’s way towards opacity.” But this answer, which is predicated on the double standards – or, as Cohen puts it, Israel being “treated in a very, very different way, and rightly so” – completely ignores the reality faced by the state of Israel today. In fact, it positions Israel as the “existential” threat, affirming the framing that Israel’s actions are the sole issue needing justification.

The “big Arab world hostile” to Israel (and Persian nuclear-weapons aspiring Iran) is the crux of the issue. The Islamic Republic of Iran is not just a country that is at war with Israel, or a country that wants to be on even ground with its regional neighbour. The regime was founded on, in part, the Islamist goal of eradicating the West, and Jewish state, which it considers occupied “Palestine.” The regime has fuelled, funded, and maintained a proxy war with terror groups across the region, all targeting Israel, for decades.

Without acknowledging Iran’s hostile rhetoric and proxy war, from our vantage point the episode enables a framing where the Islamic Regime’s safety is at the behest of Israel’s nuclear efforts, not vice versa.

To be sure, Cohen elaborates, the US is not in control of Israeli policy on this matter, but neither is there “any danger of use of Israeli nuclear weapons, and everybody knows that.” But the episode does not use this to counterbalance the framing that Israel’s opacity is a moral problem, let alone a security issue.

Lastly, Cohen talks extensively about how Israel is treated in a different way than other countries, though he neglects to attribute this to antisemitism. The nature of the topic as secretive and mysterious is factually grounded, but without careful language and context-building, the discussion inadvertently alludes to the idea that Israel is hiding something dangerous and morally suspect, which in our view mirrors the antisemitic trope of Jews as secretive, powerful and shadowy controllers of society. At its core, the May 21 episode of CBC’s Front Burner with Jayme Poisson interviewing Avner Cohen about “Israel’s open nuclear secret” is a discussion of a complex, obscure policy that is a legitimate topic. With only one guest who critiques opacity and minimal (if any) challenge to his claims, and notable language choices, the segment lacks balance and due fairness required by the CBC’s Journalistic Standards and Practices.                                        

Photo Credit: Jayme Poisson

Comments