CBC Winnipeg Radio Host Faith Fundal Produces One-Sided Anti-Israel Coverage Of Controversial “Nakba” Exhibit Planned For Canadian Museum Of Human Rights

The CBC radio program Up to speed with Faith Fundal broadcast a segment on November 21 entitled, “Jewish Winnipegger supports Nakba exhibit.”

In it, Fundal interviewed Daniel Thau-Eleff, a local playwright and a so-called “member of the Winnipeg Jewish community” on the subject of what Fundal called the “New exhibit at the Canadian museum for human rights that is drawing some national attention. It’s called Palestine uprooted: Nakba past and present. It recounts the personal experiences of Palestinian Canadians, forced, who fled their homes in 1948 before coming to Winnipeg.”

Click below to listen to the segment:

Fundal recounted that, as a result of the Canadian Museum of Human Rights (CMHR) hosting this exhibit, the Jewish Heritage Center of Western Canada has withdrawn from this year’s Holocaust remembrance day at the CMHR, and the Jewish Federation of Winnipeg also expressed concern that “the exhibit may present a narrow and one-sided picture of this complex history” and added, “It also carries a real risk during a period when antisemitism in Canada has risen to levels never seen before.” Their concerns were not addressed in the segment.

Also what went unsaid is that Isha Khan, Director of the CMHR, is the Founder of the Canadian Council of Muslim Women’s Winnipeg chapter. The CCMW has put out a statement “In Solidarity with Palestine” labelling Israel as an “apartheid regime.”

Rather than interviewing any critics, Thau Eleff stated that he finds the controversy “beyond upsetting.” He also referred to “the ‘ethnic cleansing’, in Ilan Pappe’s words, that the State of Israel was founded on, and including the human rights abuses that continue to this day…”

An appropriate moment for Fundal to provide some context and clarification that Thau-Eleff’s sources are all fringe sources. Thau-Eleff himself is a member of Independent Jewish Voices (IJV) – an anti-Israel organization who in 2024 sponsored an anti-Israel protest which praised the “beautiful, brave and heroic resistance of the Palestinian people.”

As for Ilan Pappe, he was accused by Israeli historian Benny Morris of being “at best… one of the world’s sloppiest historians; at worst, one of the most dishonest.” Hardly a reputable source.

Accusing Israel of “ethnic cleansing” is ridiculous. Arabs are fully present in all walks of Israeli lives, including in the Knesset. Some 20 percent of Israelis are Arabs with full and equal rights as Jewish-Israelis. As for human rights abuses, anything that happens under Israeli rule is subject to the rule of law, and is judged in the courts. Fundal’s acceptance of these extreme allegations with no evidence shows bias.

Thau-Eleff also referenced support for the exhibition from the fringe anti-Israel Jewish Faculty Network as well as United Jewish People’s Order, another radical group whom NGO Monitor said has worked with Samidoun, which has been recognized by the US and Canada as a terrorist entity.

Thau-Eleff continued to say that concerns about the exhibit come from defensiveness and ethnocentrism and are opposed to human rights and “peaceful coexistence.”

In fact, the Canadian Jewish News reported that “the Federation has ‘repeatedly and respectfully tried to engage the museum’ about the exhibit, adding they hope ‘it will pause its plans until it begins a proper, open consultation process and grounds the exhibit in credible research that reflects the full historical record. Our community stands ready to participate in that work.’”

Fundal and Thau-Eleff left out that mainstream Jewish organizations want to be involved, they are not asking for the event to be cancelled. It is hard to understand why they are being blamed for being opposed to coexistence, when the CMHR is the one who is not engaging with them.

Perhaps the Jewish organizations want to ensure the CMHR includes that Israel was legally established following the League of Nations’ (precursor to the United Nations) two-state solution which the Jews accepted and the Arabs rejected. It is also relevant that five Arab armies chose to descend on nascent Israel in 1948, intent on its immediate destruction, creating Israel’s War of Independence. Some Arab leaders called for Arabs to leave prior, assured that they would shortly return victorious, able to “obtain their share of abandoned Jewish property.”

Maybe they want the exhibition to include Israeli Ambassador Abba Eban’s timeless 1958 statement, “let there be no mistake. If there had been no war against Israel, with its consequent harvest of bloodshed, misery, panic and flight, there would be no problem of Arab refugees today.”

The 850,000 Jews expelled from Arab lands and Iran following the establishment of the State of Israel, a fact that is often deleted from the Arab Nakba narrative, is also relevant. But none of this was acknowledged in Fundal and Thau-Eleff’s whitewashing of opposing views. They appear to want coexistence for echo chamber residents only.

As for Fundal stating that a request was made to the Winnipeg Jewish Federation and Jewish Heritage Centre, will there be a follow-up episode to balance the narrative?

Given Fundal’s ongoing anti-Israel agenda, listeners shouldn’t expect much.

Comments