CBC & Radio-Canada Sign Anti-Israel Open Letter, Making Its Anti-Israel Agenda Crystal Clear

July 31, 2025

On July 24, CBC News reported that international reporters are facing starvation in Gaza, in their article entitled: “BBC, Reuters among 4 news organizations saying their journalists face starvation in Gaza.” In the report, CBC added that beyond these four news organizations, outlets like CBC News, the Washington Post and ABC have signed a different statement by the International News Safety Institute (INSI), “echoing similar concerns and also calling on Israel to allow other journalists into Gaza.”

This INSI statement titled: “Let Them Out. Let Us In. INSI Statement on Gaza,” proclaimed that “The death toll among journalists [in Gaza] has been staggering, almost incomprehensible. According to the Committee to Protect Journalists, more than 186 have lost their lives in 22 months.”

Signed by CBC Editor-in-Chief Brodie Fenlon and Luce Julien, the General Manager News and Current Affairs for Radio-Canada, the statement decried the ‘allowance’ of reporters being “killed, [facing] the threat of starvation, or try[ing] to flee.”

One of the “journalists” in Gaza claiming he is starving is none other than Mohamed El Saife, the propagandist-masquerading-as-a-journalist whose reports represent a significant amount of CBC News’ reporting.

Fenlon and Julien, along with the few dozen other media workers — including Paul Danahar, Foreign Editor and Callum Hunt, Head of Business, both of the BBC, along with others from ABC News, The Guardian, The Washington Post and more — listed as undersigned members of INSI, signed this letter to “call for Israel to allow any journalist and their family who wish to leave Gaza to do so, and to allow in international reporters to carry out their work.”

In the CBC News article, a freelance photographer with the outlet is spotlighted explaining how on some days “he is lucky to find half of a pita bread to eat to allow him to remain on his feet covering the latest developments on the ground — but his biggest worry is feeding his family.”

The rest of the CBC News article jumped around different aspects of the Israel-Hamas war, which it later described as: “The war…since Hamas killed some 1,200 people and took 251 hostages from southern Israel in the deadliest single attack in Israel’s history,” immediately followed by describing Israel as having “killed nearly 60,000 Palestinians in Gaza, decimated Hamas as a military force.”

Unsurprisingly, it quoted the death count by the Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry – uncritically referenced earlier on in the article, too – which did not discern between militants and civilians. The article also referred to the statement by “100 charity and human rights groups [saying] that Israel’s blockade and ongoing military offensive are pushing Palestinians in the Gaza Strip toward starvation.”

Two things are important to note in relation to the reporting by the CBC News and the INSI statement.

First, it remains a consistently neglected fact that many of the journalists that have died in the Gaza Strip during the Israel-Hamas war are openly affiliated with terrorist groups in the territory and the broader region. That this is omitted nearly constantly is part of a broader effort to pin all the blame on Israel for the hostilities during the war.

It was also recently revealed that a leaked email from the BBC’s executive editor – the network that is a signatory of both the INSI statement and the joint statement with the Associated Press and co. – instructed BBC journalists “covering the food crisis in Gaza” to make no effort to investigate the aid situation in Gaza. In the leaked memo, the executive editor told BBC journalists that it did not matter how much aid was sent into the territory, it should simply be reported that the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation “doesn’t work.”

With explicit proof that the BBC purposefully promoted a predetermined narrative about the aid situation in Gaza, it begs the question: what else is being reported in this manner? The aforementioned example, of ‘journalists’ with explicit ties to terrorist groups, has consistently been ignored by the media, despite its direct culpability.

CBC and Radio-Canada, by putting its name, its reputation, and its responsibility for trustworthy reporting, funded by the Canadian public, on this statement by the International News Safety Institute should not be surprising at this point; Canada’s public broadcaster has for many months made little attempt to hide its anti-Israel activism, under the banner of presenting news.

But by signing onto this statement, just as The Globe & Mail did only weeks before with a similar letter, CBC has reminded Canadians of the need to hold news media outlets accountable, not just for what they report, but when they decide to drop all pretenses and come clean about their anti-Israel advocacy.

July 31, 2025
July 31, 2025

Comments