CBC Podcast Front Burner Continues Its Fixation With Israel In Latest Episode On AIPAC

The June 8 episode of CBC’s podcast Front Burner, hosted by Jayme Poisson, featured Alex Shephard of The New Republic magazine. At the core of the 35-minute segment, “The backlash against AIPAC,” features both the host and guest not in our view recognizing antisemitism as an active force in the story they are telling. And this pattern starts from the ground up.

Listen to the full segment below:

Their discussion centers on the change in relationship between the Democratic Party in the United States and the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and looks at the platforms of various candidates currently running for office. But Poisson launches this discussion with the divisive candidacy of Graham Platner – who won Maine’s Democratic Senate primary on June 9 – and his unfounded claim that “incumbent Republican Senator Susan Collins, is bought and paid for by Israeli President (sic) Benjamin Netanyahu.”

Poisson was quick to dismiss the claim as untrue, but uses it as a jumping off point to open discussion around how “he’s referring to is the sizable chunk of Collins’ fundraising that comes from AIPAC” and that “the AIPAC brand is increasingly toxic for Democrats.”

Analysis of this topic would not be problematic in principle. The problem lies in the recent slew of episodes that precede this particular episode of Front Burner. “Israel’s open nuclear secret,” (May 21) “Canada and the politics of Gaza flotillas,” (May 22) and “Does a ‘peace deal’ fuel Middle Eastern war?” (June 1) – these are all episodes within the last few weeks, and all three prompted HonestReporting Canada alerts.

This episode in particular contributes to Front Burner’s fixation on Israel and its supporters, this time in looking at AIPAC and the pro-Israel lobby in the era of, as Shephard calls it, without evidence, “the genocide in Gaza.”

Shephard’s casual use of “genocide” – a practice we have repeatedly highlighted is an unproven legal libel – is accompanied by various inflammatory claims made by political candidates who, beyond merely criticizing AIPAC, deployed what we consider to be incendiary rhetoric that both Shephard and Poisson left unaddressed. For example, Platner is quoted saying, “What is happening in Gaza…it’s the moral question of our time.”

U.S. Congressman Thomas Massie is quoted as saying “oh, hell no. I’m [not] antisemitic. But here’s the danger that AIPAC runs…[they push for the idea that] anti-Zionism equals anti-Semitism.”

Michigan candidate Abdul Al-Sayed is quoted making a similar claim: “it’s AIPAC money, which is being spent already in this race… I don’t think that our taxpayer dollars, which we pay every April, ought to be going to bomb children, to fund bombs and tanks for other countries when we got kids who can’t afford basic things on our own.”

Massie is quoted, for example, disparaging “the Israeli lobby, AIPAC, the Republican Jewish Coalition…” – that is, it is not just AIPAC, but rather this larger matter of Jewish influence and power that Massie takes issue with.

Al-Sayed prompted his earlier assessment about AIPAC and the war by saying, “I’m the only candidate who didn’t ask AIPAC for their support;” that is, not taking AIPAC money is morally virtuous in the face of “bomb[ing] children.”

Similarly, the morality of Israel’s so-called “genocide in Gaza,” as Platner called it, is framed by Shephard as “a real litmus test” that will challenge Democratic politics moving forward.

All of these quotes, and more, are used as the backbone of a discussion into AIPAC’s role in American politics and the future of the Democratic relationship with Israel. These claims are not policy disagreement; in our view they directly contribute to and rely on the conspiratorial notion of Jewish global power and control, extended contemporarily to the Jewish state.

But to identify the framing of this discussion on Front Burner, one only need to go back to the very first minute of the episode: Poisson dismisses Platner’s claim about Susan Collins being “bought and paid for” by Netanyahu (not AIPAC), then in our estimation goes on to validate the framework by pivoting to AIPAC money and influence for the entire episode.

To be sure, AIPAC is undoubtedly a pro-Israel lobby group, and it is not above criticism. The crux of the issue lies not in the fact that Poisson and Shephard are scrutinizing AIPAC as it tries to maintain bipartisan support for the U.S.-Israel relationship amidst a complex, heated regional moment. It lies in the fact that the entire framing of the episode – one of many – paints Israel and Israeli concerns as suspect.

Plenty of other communities, countries, and issues drive lobby groups – many of which are more influential than AIPAC. But for CBC’s Front Burner, Israel is often subject to a spotlight not provided to other communities, countries or special interests. This selectivity, alongside host Jayme Poisson and guests repeatedly missing the antisemitism that drives disproportionate scrutiny, results in not just a failure to identify antisemitism, but a dangerous affirmation of the very claims that rely on it.

Comments