In a July 20 interview on CBC News, Victoria Rose, a London, Ontario-based plastic surgeon who has visited Gaza, was permitted to launch into an anti-Israel tirade for more than eight minutes, parroting multiple lies, and was not challenged once by her host, Natasha Fatah.
In the segment entitled: “Gaza facing ‘man-made famine,’ says doctor after humanitarian missions,” Rose stated that “there’s no food in Gaza and there’s been no food in Gaza since the second of March, so they’re starving.” She later repeated herself for good measure, saying “there is no food. There is no food left in Gaza. These people are starving.”
Click to watch the full segment:
This is not simply an inaccurate statement, it is a lie. Since the founding of the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) in late May, some 85 million meals have been distributed to the people there, in addition to food being grown and created locally, plus aid coming in from other sources.
By any metric, tens of millions of meals could not be counted as “no food,” but this disinformation was able to stand entirely unchallenged.
Such hysterical claims were followed by yet more outlandish statements from Rose, who at one point said that “pictures are coming out (of Gaza) that equate the same sorts of pictures that we saw in the 80s in Ethiopia.”
Unfortunately for Rose, viewers were shown footage during her comments that flatly showed the hollowness of her claims, with images from Gaza showing people ranging from healthy in appearance to even obese, nowhere close to the emaciated and skeletal figures seen in actual famines like Ethiopia and Nigeria’s Biafra region in the 1980s.
In supposedly “starving” Gaza, as Rose would have Canadians believe, there are bustling markets and active restaurants, bakeries and other specialty stores, hardly hallmarks of what one would see in a famine-ravaged locale.
These claims from Rose, as detached from reality as they were, not once were given any challenge or pushback from Fatah, nor did viewers get any context or correction from the host.
While Fatah did state that her program had contacted GHF for an interview and did not hear back, there were many other spokespeople who could have shared their expertise, including from the Israeli government or other subject matter experts. Allowing Rose to speak authoritatively while simultaneously spreading baseless disinformation did not further any journalistic goal, only an ideological one.
Notably absent from the entire segment was any mention of Hamas, the Palestinian Islamic terrorist group that started the war on October 7, 2023 with its massacres in Israel, and which continues to hold dozens of Israelis hostage. But Israelis are not its only victims. It has siphoned off aid from Gaza – a point even critics of Israel have admitted – and strong evidence suggests that it has been responsible for attacks at aid distribution sites, both against aid workers and against Gazans trying to get food.
These are not minor points, but reflect the crux of the issue. While it would be expected that Rose would choose to ignore details that disprove her claims, there is no reason why CBC News would obscure this from the Canadian public.
Canadians deserve to hear the real truth from Gaza, not a carefully constructed false narrative that goes completely unchallenged by their publicly-funded broadcaster.






