Abby Cole’s September 10 CBC News article entitled: “Newfoundlanders setting sail on global flotillas en route to Gaza on aid mission” was another example of the reporter’s style when it comes to articles related to Israel: a one-sided, selectively sourced piece, this time about the Global Sumud Flotilla.
Cole noted that three Newfoundland activists and a Canadian law professor are on board the flotilla, which is “aimed at disrupting Israel’s blockade on Gaza and delivering humanitarian aid.” She wrote that “for months, the Israeli government has sustained a blockade on humanitarian supplies from entering Gaza.”
Cole linked to an April article about the blockade. Israel’s 11-week blockade on Gaza ended May 19. It is long over, and preceding it, Gaza was sent many months’ worth of aid.
Cole continued by stating that “in August, the leading global authority on food insecurity declared famine in Gaza City.” True, the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) did. But to do so, they altered the famine threshold and used incomplete data. It has been thoroughly challenged and debunked.
Cole ignored that the Israeli and US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) has delivered more than 165 million meals to date, and that Gazan social media shows food aplenty, with restaurants open and groceries full of food. The Israeli organization COGAT, which coordinates aid, reports that 129,514 tonnes of aid entered Gaza in August alone. Cole didn’t square this data with her apocalyptic claims.
Her next accusation was that “world leading genocide scholars” have declared a genocide in Gaza. The International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS) relied on Hamas-run Gaza Health Ministry figures that do not differentiate between civilians and combatants. Additionally, IAGS membership credentials are only a $30 payment, and even then, only 28% of its membership even voted.
Cole didn’t include any of this data to balance her unilateral blame of Israel. Neither did she explain why Israel is at war: to neutralize their genocidal neighbour – Hamas – who wants to wipe them off the map. She likewise whitewashed Hamas’ role in stealing and reselling aid at inflated prices to fund their terror machine, as well as threatening Gazans who would pick up aid from the GHF.
Instead, she shared a video from CBC darling Heidi Matthews, assistant professor in the Faculty of Law at Osgoode Law School, who, after October 7 signed an open letter that we regard as having rationalized Hamas’ atrocities, and has failed to denounce Hamas’s ‘resistance’ on social media.
Matthews is on the flotilla for as she claims ‘legal support’, and Cole included a video of her sharing their intent to break the “siege on Gaza,” among other things. Matthews said of the flotilla effort, “they are not carrying arms, they’re not affiliated with terrorist organizations, they pose no threat to Israel, all this is total obfuscation and absurdity.”
Except that it isn’t quite so innocent. Four steering committee members have alleged links to terror organizations, including participant Muhammad Nadir Al-Nuri who reportedly has connections to Hamas.
Likewise, the fact that the Freedom Flotilla Coalition, one of the organizers of the flotilla, lists the IHH as a member. The IHH, banned in Israel and Germany, is linked to terror organization Hamas.
Cole’s portrayal of the flotilla as a serious humanitarian aid mission is curious. Surely a humanitarian aid mission would partner with existing and experienced aid organizations? Wouldn’t they publicize the quantities of aid on board?
Cole also gave a lot of space to the organizers’ claim that a drone attacked the boat, albeit including Tunisia’s rebuttal of the claim. HonestReporting has noted that the video Matthews used shows something hitting the deck that was already aflame – not the case with drone missiles, and that this could have been a publicity stunt.
Cole has written another utterly one-sided, biased, anti-Israel article, misleading readers and sanitizing extreme views.






