CBC News Report By Chris Brown Overlooks Hezbollah’s Infiltration Of Civilian Infrastructure

In an uncharacteristically balanced broadcast on May 6, “What it will take to disarm Hezbollah,” Chris Brown, foreign correspondent for CBC News, told viewers about the extensive tentacles that Hezbollah, the Iranian-backed terrorist group, has throughout Lebanon, and how it has dragged the country into war with neighbouring Israel.

Watch the full segment below:

If Brown’s report was to be the beginning of a positive trend in his coverage of the Middle East, it appeared to be short-lived. The following day, Brown authored an article on the same topic, “Why disarming Hezbollah is about much more than guns and rockets.”

To his credit, in the report Brown acknowledged that Hezbollah “dragged Lebanon into another war by attacking Israel, largely at the behest of its masters in Iran.”

However, much of the article falsely equated Hezbollah’s terrorism – which has targeted both Israeli soldiers and civilians alike – with Israel’s efforts to protect itself against a menace which, like its patron in Tehran, seeks the violent annihilation of Israel.

In fact, nowhere in the article were readers told that, rather than simply being a militia seeking to fight for Lebanese sovereignty, Hezbollah is a fanatical Islamic terrorist group that seeks the destruction of Israel in its entirety. Had that context been included, readers would understand that it is a party that cannot be reasoned with or negotiated with, and will never accept anything less than Israel’s destruction.

In his article, Brown referred to “a brutal Israeli military campaign annihilating emptied-out communities across the country’s south,” depicting Israel’s counter-terrorism operations as if they were random, and not aimed at degrading Hezbollah’s extensive infiltration throughout southern Lebanon.

In cities and towns such as Bint Jbeil, virtually the entire locale was converted into a giant Hezbollah base, with weapons storage, subterranean tunnels and deeply-embedded fighters, whose thorough integration into virtually every nook and cranny in the town created a situation where there was no place where Hezbollah was not present.

Brown repeatedly emphasized the scale of destruction in Lebanon, characterizing Bint Jbeil and elsewhere as being “a Gaza-like moonscape of crushed rubble,” in a clear evocation of emotions for readers.

For Canadian eyes unused to war, such destruction may be shocking and could be easily used to suggest that destruction in Lebanon implies Israel’s guilt, but this is not so. During World War Two, many German cities resembled the “moonscape” to which Brown is referring, though that does not mean Nazi Germany was righteous while the Allies were wicked.

Brown could have included a number of important details to help readers understand the extent of Hezbollah’s infiltration throughout southern Lebanon, as well as noting Israel’s statements to that effect.

In mid-April, the Israeli military announced that its soldiers had “eliminated more than 100 terrorists…destroyed dozens of terrorist infrastructure, and located hundreds of weapons in the area” inside the town of Bint Jbeil. Even pro-Hezbollah websites made no effort to hide the fact that such locales were thoroughly part of the terrorist group’s operations.

In another case, Israel released footage showing Hezbollah’s use of an ambulance in order to transport weapons.

While Chris Brown’s video broadcast represented an improvement over much of his previous reporting, his accompanying news article downplayed the extent of Hezbollah’s use of civilian infrastructure in southern Lebanon and beyond, and falsely equated the group’s terrorism with Israel’s efforts to protect itself from those same bloody attacks.

Comments