Israeli journalist Haviv Rettig Gur recently noted that “anyone who talks about famine in Gaza and of Israel’s manifest responsibility to prevent it but refuses to notice that Hamas actively and violently disrupts all aid channels it can’t control, that it still seeks more and endless war and destruction in Gaza…is only helping to ensure more war and suffering.”
This principle rings especially true in contemporary media reporting, where the portrayal of Palestinian suffering is rendered as a straight line: Palestinians suffer; therefore, Israel is the singular, axiomatic culprit.
This framing is especially clear in a CBC News’ The National segment by Nahlah Ayed on July 22 entitled: “100 humanitarian organizations plead for Gaza aid to resume.” Ayed, who has consistently produced biased anti-Israel reporting which has been documented by HonestReporting Canada many times, set the scene for CBC viewers in an emotionally charged manner: “Imagine the desperation it takes to wade into this.” She was referring to a scene in which a group of men crowd around an aid truck, quickly and chaotically grabbing supplies.
Click below to watch the full segment:
What followed was a quote from an interviewee injured in the crowd, Muhammad Abu Jabal, explaining how he “went to die” to provide food for his children. “This bag,” he claimed, “is soaked with blood.”
Ayed and the CBC zoomed out to offer what appears to be context: aid is now distributed by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a U.S. and Israeli-backed initiative, and “the UN says hundreds of Palestinians have been shot trying to access” that aid. Ayed then noted that while Israel has acknowledged the shortage of aid, it blames the UN and denies there is a famine — quite a skeptical framing for Israel.
There is no apparent attempt to consider other claims or factors that hinder the logistics of aid delivery in Gaza. The full picture is omitted.
Specifically, it has been reported that the United Nations (UN) has aid sitting at the border, and the GHF has offered to deliver the aid — which the UN has rejected. To be specific, Israel has pointed out that any humanitarian situation can be addressed with cooperation, and that even the delivery of the hundreds of trucks at the border would change the situation drastically. The UN refused to cooperate with the GHF, accusing the latter of setting up operations that endanger the local population.
Hamas, unsurprisingly, is the major elephant in the room. In its criticism of the GHF, the UN refuses to acknowledge that the terror group targets aid efforts it cannot benefit from. And it certainly bears repeating, but “Israel’s expanded offensive into central Gaza” that Ayed reported “is threatening the last lifelines keeping Palestinians alive” would cease if accountability was properly handed to Hamas for holding Israelis hostage and refusing a ceasefire again and again.
While criticism is scathingly handed to Israel, the terror group plays no role in how the humanitarian situation is reported, omitted entirely from the spectrum of responsibility in the conflict — a shared pattern in media and humanitarian entities.
To further reinforce the principle of unilateral Israeli culpability, Ayed interviewed Rachael Cummings, a Save the Children team leader and frequent guest on CBC News, who remarked that, “we need humanitarian supplies to come into Gaza at scale. We need the bombs to stop dropping on children.” Another interviewee, Canadian nurse Jack Latour, described how difficult it was for her to address the needs of parents advocating for their children to get treatment for malnourishment.
Rettig Gur highlighted how the chain of responsibility is consistently traced back to one actor: Israel. And while the future does remain “uncertain,” as Ayed concluded, it remains certain that refusing to hold the terrorist group that started this all on October 7, 2023 accountable, will not bring about clarity. Rather, it will only perpetuate the crisis at hand.






