CBC News Correspondent Paul Hunter Turns Complex Story Of Building Permits Into Anti-Israel Hit Piece

In an October 3 recent segment, “Palestinians in West Bank’s Jordan Valley fear Israeli annexation,” CBC News once again abandoned balance for a tear-jerker anti-Israel narrative.

Click below to watch the segment:

Correspondent Paul Hunter presented emotional Palestinian testimony with minimal Israeli context. In doing so, he managed to transform a complex legal and historical issue into a simple story of victim and aggressor.

As Hunter put it, “Israel is slowly, surely moving toward taking much of this… annexing the fertile lands farmed by Palestinians for so long.”

This frames Israel as an aggressor “taking” land. In reality, the region’s legal status is far from established as Palestinian. It has never been part of a sovereign Palestinian nation. This misled listeners into thinking annexation is ongoing, and that such an act would be illegal.

Hunter’s casual reference to Palestinians farming there “for so long” merits investigation. By not mentioning exactly how long, Hunter glossed over two inconvenient facts. First, much of that disputed land was originally Jewish (not only in ancient times, but also right before the 1948 War of Independence). And second, many people who claim “Palestinian” ancestry actually migrated to Ottoman or British Palestine from what is now Syria, Jordan, and Egypt, chasing economic opportunity.

Hunter included dramatic scenes like this one: “Ibrahim Salameh surveys the rubble which, until two weeks ago, was his house… Israeli forces pulled up with heavy equipment and flattened it, saying he had no permit.”

This would have been a perfect opportunity for Salameh to show legal documentation, such as a building permit. Or for Hunter to speak to a legal expert to discuss the complicated reality on the ground. But instead he chose to tell a much simpler story.

There’s nothing like rubble to touch viewers’ hearts. Never mind that it also distracts them from the total absence of Israeli voices or legal experts. And that Hunter’s picture is incomplete.

Here’s the truth: Under the 1993 Oslo Accords between Israel and the Palestinian leadership, Palestinians agreed that Israel will administer land between Palestinian-controlled areas. That includes enforcing building regulations, just like Canadian municipalities like Toronto and Vancouver do. Even in Canada, that includes demolishing homes built without permits. The Israeli military demolishes all illegal structures, whether built by Palestinians or built by Israelis.

But none of that would have suited the one-sided narrative Hunter was ostensibly trying to weave for CBC viewers. Instead, he framed his story around Palestinian “fears” that Israel will snatch their land. “Hence, so many Palestinians in the West Bank… still fear the threat of annexation there.”

Hunter failed to point out that despite these “fears,” no annexation has occurred. Instead, he played up Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s 2019 campaign promise to “take the Jordan valley.” But as he himself admitted, Netanyahu has never implemented this pledge, meaning that the fears, if they exist, are unfounded.

No matter how you slice it, routine enforcement of building permit violations does not equal “annexation.”

With Palestinians in Hunter’s report helplessly asking, “what have we done? Why is this happening?” he painted Israel as a faceless, unreasoning aggressor. Hunter’s moralistic condemnation and absence of facts gave CBC News viewers a distorted view of Israel as a predatory force.

As a taxpayer-funded outlet, CBC News must uphold higher journalistic standards — including accuracy, context, and fairness – all of which were missing from Hunter’s report.

Comments