CBC News Airs Report Of Two Canadian Doctors Spreading Anti-Israel Disinformation Unchallenged

A CBC broadcast aired on July 11 entitled: “Canadian doctors work in Gaza as fuel shortages threaten lives, hospitals” exploited the suffering of Gazan civilians and the humanitarian sensibilities of Canadian viewers as a propaganda tool for anti-Israel lies and policies.

Watch the full segment below:

The segment featured a short profile of two Canadian medical professionals who are spending a few weeks in the Gaza Strip helping out at the Shuhada Al-Aqsa hospital (a facility which Israel has previously alleged Hamas operatives to be conducting military activities from — a contextual point never mentioned by CBC News). The doctors shared their observations about the challenges and issues facing those caught in the crossfires of the ongoing war.

While this story is of course worth telling, this segment unfortunately was not presented in an appropriate or responsible manner by CBC’s team.

The segment provided no context or background whatsoever, omitted information critical to understanding the issues being discussed, and allowed itself to be a platform for political propaganda — all of which turned an ostensibly humanitarian and sympathetic story into a nefarious, cynical piece of anti-Israel emotional propaganda.

Ending off two straight minutes of bleak descriptions of the tragic conditions in these hospitals, the doctors abruptly declared that “the blockade has to stop immediately,” that “there is no reason on earth that you [should] starve a kid,” and that their activities are “a gesture of solidarity” despite what “our governments may decide to do.”

The editors of this segment, by tacking these overtly political comments onto the tail end of the piece, have allowed suffering to be weaponized. And, as such, they deserve a response, some balance and context, and a fact-check — all things that CBC News neglected entirely to even attempt to offer here.

Calling for an end to the “blockade” in Gaza is a slogan Canadians have heard ubiquitously from anti-Israel activists for two decades, long predating the current war and crisis. From the moment that Hamas terrorists seized control of the Gaza Strip in 2006, these activists have decried any effort by Israel to monitor what enters in the territory in order to protect lives by preventing the violent genocidal terrorists who started this war from obtaining weapons. One cannot blame Israel for the impact of its security policies without so much as an acknowledgment of the party who is directly responsible for both that policy and the ongoing fighting — Hamas.

Instead of providing an unchallenged platform from which to spew these baseless statements, CBC News should have provided relevant facts and context. They should have clarified that there was no “blockade” when Israel voluntarily withdrew its entire military and civilian presence from the entire Gaza Strip in 2005, handing the area over to the Palestinians to pursue their national aspirations.

Yet, did this lead to an end to the suffering of innocents, including children? Quite the opposite. It led to the development of one of the highest rates of childhood post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in the world on the Israeli side of the border, as Hamas took power and began indiscriminately shooting rockets on a daily basis at targets like playgrounds, schools, and homes.

It also led to Hamas’ October 7 attacks, in which 1, 200 Israelis were brutally mudered, including dozens of children (including babies) who were violently massacred and/or taken hostage. How can they claim to be standing up for children and demanding an end to measures that contain Hamas’ cruelty in the same breath? And how could CBC News sit by and let this be said without any follow-up or correction?

Furthermore, the implications about the “blockade” itself are vastly overstated and misleading. Despite the picture that activists like to paint, Israel does not maintain a “siege” over the Gaza Strip. On the contrary, it actively facilitates the constant entry of thousands of aid trucks bringing food and supplies to the civilian population — only preventing weapons and dangerous materials from getting in. It is Hamas and its violent gangs, not Israel, who then systematically steals and hoards this aid, gouging access to food for average people and diverting fuel from hospitals to instead power its own terror tunnel network. Israel, on the other hand, backs the US-led Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) organization and protects its ability to operate amidst this dangerous setting, ensuring that civilians who need food do indeed have a way of accessing it.

The very presence of these two Canadian doctors in Gaza on a multi-week humanitarian visit openly proves that Israel is allowing legitimate humanitarian entries to take place despite the so-called blockade. Not only is Gaza not hermetically sealed as is often claimed, Israel allows international medical professionals to enter the territory and facilitates the influx of humanitarian aid.

If this was really about humanitarian concern for civilians, the comments at the end would have called for Hamas to surrender and end the war. They would have called for civilians to take part in the US and Israeli-backed aid program which is readily available to those who seek it out. They would have called for civilians to comply with Israeli military guidelines to minimize risks of danger. They would have called for the hostages to be released, or to receive the same urgent medical attention they purport to broadly care about. And they would have called for Egypt to stop preventing civilians from fleeing the war zone.

But they didn’t, and neither did anyone else in this report. Which reveals the true effective message of this piece — taking advantage of suffering to score cheap PR points for anti-Israel politics, all given an unchallenged platform by our public broadcaster.

Comments