CBC Early Edition, A Repeated Platformer Of Anti-Israel Disinformation, Hosts “Genocide”-Alleging Nurse Deidre Nunan, A Frequent CBC Guest

September 17, 2025

On September 8, CBC Radio’s The Early Edition program hosted a segment titled: “B.C.-trained doctor shares what she saw in Gaza this summer”, featuring host Stephen Quinn and guest Deirdre Nunan, a Canadian nurse. Quinn’s program has a history of anti-Israel bias, and Nunan has repeatedly spread anti-Israel misinformation on various CBC programs. Unfortunately, this broadcast continued the troubling pattern of presenting the war in Gaza through a distorted lens, omitting critical context, and blaming Israel for the region’s humanitarian and security crises.

During the segment, Quinn and Nunan emphasized the suffering of Gaza’s population, with Nunan describing a “catastrophic famine” and injuries to civilians allegedly shot while attempting to access food aid. While the human toll of the conflict is undeniable, their narrative was deeply misleading in several key ways.

Click here to listen to the segment:

Firstly, the broadcast repeatedly ignored the role of Hamas and other terrorist groups in creating the humanitarian crisis. Israel’s military operations are focused on Hamas infrastructure, including rocket launch sites, command centres, and tunnel networks used to attack civilians. Independent reporting confirms that Hamas deliberately embeds military assets within civilian infrastructure, a tactic designed to manipulate public perception and maximize casualties among their own civilian population. Presenting the suffering in Gaza without acknowledging Hamas’ responsibility, as Nunan did, offered Canadians an incomplete and skewed account of events.

As well, Quinn and Nunan’s claims of “human-caused famine” ignored the widespread availability of food and aid in Gaza. Nunan herself noted that food exists just across the border, but she framed shortages as a deliberate Israeli strategy rather than the result of Hamas’ obstruction, diversion and theft of aid and supplies for military purposes. In fact, there have been repeated reports that Hamas controls and sometimes blocks the distribution of food, water, and medical supplies to maintain leverage over Gaza’s population. By failing to mention these facts, CBC misled listeners into believing Israel is solely responsible for civilian suffering.

Further, the broadcast minimized attacks against Israeli civilians. Quinn and Nunan briefly referenced a shooting in Jerusalem that killed six people (and wounded 21 others), yet Quinn immediately proffered that Hamas denied involvement – a blatant lie, at least according to several sources. Importantly, the day after this segment was broadcast, Hamas proudly claimed responsibility for the attack.

Additionally troubling, the segment suggested journalists reporting from Gaza are systematically killed by Israel, omitting verified reports that many casualties result from Hamas’ own attacks or or stem from the fact that many of these “journalists” are nothing more than terrorists in press vests or are not members of the media at all. The recent case of Anas al-Sharif being a prime example of this.

Quinn, who has previously hosted anti-Israel activists such as Michael Lynk with minimal challenge, allowed Nunan to make sweeping statements about Israel committing “hospital attacks” and keeping Gaza “under siege” without any counterbalance. Nunan, a regular CBC guest who has openly signed petitions singling out Israel while ignoring Hamas’ crimes, continued her pattern of presenting a one-sided narrative that ignores the suffering of Israeli civilians and the strategic complexities faced by Israel.

Nunan supported calls for an “end to genocide” without acknowledging that multiple independent authorities, including the UK government, have concluded that Israel is not committing genocide according to the recent UK Foreign Office letter from September 1. Such statements, while perhaps understandable when coming from someone with no discernible training in international law or knowledge of the realities of urban combat, were presented uncritically and elevated emotion-fueled political advocacy over factual reporting.

CBC’s The Early Edition once again failed to provide balanced reporting. The program presented Gaza exclusively through the lens of suffering while omitting Hamas’ role in perpetuating the conflict, ignoring Israeli civilian casualties, and failing to contextualize Israel’s military and humanitarian decisions.

September 17, 2025
September 17, 2025

Comments