CBC As It Happens Interviews Representative From “Humanitarian” Group Norwegian Refugee Council, Whose Apocalyptic Depiction Of Gaza Bears No Resemblance To Reality Presented By Gazans Themselves

The gulf between what so-called ‘humanitarian’ groups are describing in Gaza, and the actual reality on the ground, continues to widen.

While social media footage from actual Gazans show locals enjoying fresh fruits, imported meat, upscale cafes and shopping malls, anti-Israel activists have been appearing on Canadian news media outlets, where they are presenting an apocalyptic image of Gaza which bears almost no resemblance to what people there are showing.

On the November 19 episode of the CBC radio program As It Happens, co-host Nil Köksal spoke with Shaina Low, a spokesperson for the Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC), a regular guest on CBC programs.

Click below to listen to the segment:

The program began with co-host Chris Howden falsely stating that “the UN estimates that more than 80% of the buildings in Gaza were destroyed in the war.” In fact, that figure includes both destroyed or damaged, meaning that many buildings have suffered fixable repairs. Far more importantly, this context utterly ignores the reason for such destruction, namely Hamas’ widespread use of tunnels underneath civilian infrastructure and using residential homes and neighbourhoods as human shields.

Despite Low being based in Amman, Jordan – more than 200 kilometres from Gaza – she was treated as an expert in the humanitarian situation there. The interview featured Low saying that “people are living in incredibly difficult conditions,” and that “people (are) pushed to the brink of survival. People are exhausted.”

Meanwhile, food has become so plentiful in the territory that some observers are calling it a “faticide,” with data showing a higher proportion of obesity in Gaza than in Israel, and research from October showing that previous declarations of famine were based on false data.

While Köksal did briefly offer a gentle challenge to Low, citing Israeli statements about the large amount of humanitarian aid entering Gaza, it paled in comparison to a detailed interview with a guest who repeatedly blamed Israel for the humanitarian situation there, presenting Jerusalem as the obstacle.

However, most of Low’s comments went unchallenged, including when she said that “Israel imposed a total siege on Gaza on March 2.” What she neglected to mention was not only that the blockade was preceded by a huge increase in aid, with more than enough to sustain Gaza during the stoppage, but that it was ended after a few weeks, and aid subsequently resumed.

Low’s employer, the Norwegian Refugee Council, presents itself as a purely humanitarian endeavour, but in reality is a stridently anti-Israel activist group using legal and other means to promote its narrow agenda.

In that sense, it is hardly alone. There is a veritable cornucopia of ‘humanitarian’ groups that hold hardline anti-Israel views, but nevertheless continue to be given sympathetic and widespread treatment in the Canadian news media, including Doctors without Borders Canada (MSF Canada), Oxfam Canada, Oxfam Quebec, Amnesty International Canada, Save the Children Canada, and many others.

But rather than holding these groups accountable for their outlandish claims, they are almost never challenged, either in their statements, or their behaviour.

And even in cases when a host offers a gentle pushback, like in this case, As It Happens failed to give any platform to an Israeli representative or anyone who could have given listeners a far more accurate picture of events in Gaza. Once again, the view hostile to Israel is given overwhelming preference.

Comments