CBC As It Happens Continues To Push Its Anti-Israel Obsession With Shamelessly One-Sided Interviews

Since Gaza’s invasion of southern Israel on October 7, 2023, CBC News has acted as an amplifier of pro-Palestinian propaganda, repeatedly normalizing scores of claims against Israel leveled by activist groups, while simultaneously ignoring virtually all opposing studies.

And now, long after Hamas’ death toll claims have been debunked by statisticians and war scholars – whose findings have received zero coverage from CBC News – the taxpayer-funded broadcaster instead has now produced two new reports alleging an even higher casualty count in Gaza.

On the February 20 episode of the CBC radio program As It Happens – which has rarely found a pro-Palestinian narrative that it hasn’t decided to air – host Nil Köksal interviewed British economist Michael Spagat about his new study published in The Lancet alleging that even Hamas’ death toll figures were an undercount.

Click below to listen to the segment:

Spagat began by openly admitting that the “original motivation” for his effort was to address the “skepticism that was directed at the Gaza Ministry of Health.”

The very fact that Spagat would be interviewed, while scores of other experts who found Hamas manipulation of data were ignored, speaks volumes about Köksal’s editorial agenda.

As explained by Spagat, his study consisted of polling Gazans about their family size on October 6, 2023, and then afterwards, and estimating deaths from there.

While Köksal asked about the civilian versus combatant ratio, he admitted that “we have no direct measurement,” though that did not stop him from unsurprisingly guessing that some 90 percent of deaths were civilians.

Köksal could have – but did not – provide any pushback to his claims from experts, including noting how many civilian deaths took place, or how many Palestinians were killed by other Palestinians (but blamed on Israel), and that experts say outlandish claims like Spagat’s “rest on dubious statistical methods.”

Nor did Köksal challenge Spagat by noting that Hamas provides compensation to families who report deaths, even in the absence of any evidence whatsoever, in line with CBC practice.

As for Spagat’s unsupported guess of civilian deaths, Köksal failed to remind listeners that given Hamas’ propensity for using teenage combatants, age is not an indication of combat status.

But rather than offering listeners anything resembling balance, instead Köksal gave a sympathetic interview, and said that “Israeli media reports say that Israeli officials recently acknowledged that figures being reported by Gaza’s Health Ministry were largely accurate,” completely ignoring that the singular report was immediately denied by Israeli officials, and did not, in fact, reflect Israel’s position.

In the same episode, listeners were also treated to another segment about Gaza, also from the perspective of an anti-Israel activist, this time Salman Khalid, an emergency room physician in Milton, Ontario, about his new book Gaza: A Doctor’s Diary, about his experience working in Gaza in late 2024.

In an interview with CBC’s Camila Lewandowski, Khalid spread the “genocide” slur against Israel, an unfounded and dangerous claim to which no challenge was provided. Given that Israel took historically unprecedented steps to avoid civilian casualties, even while fighting a proudly genocidal Islamic terrorist group, Hamas, CBC’s repeated decision to normalize and platform “genocide” claims while censoring opposition is indefensible.

CBC News also re-published an article from Thomson Reuters newswire on February 19, “Death toll in Gaza far higher in first 15 months of war than reported, new peer-reviewed study says,” reporting on Spagat’s allegations.

Like the radio interview, the news article only gave a passing mention about the unreliability of casualty data from the Hamas-run “Health Ministry.” It also ignored all statistical and methodological challenges of the allegations, instead using an ideologically motivated project as the basis for ‘news.’

In recent weeks, a study found widespread and systemic anti-Israel bias at CBC News, but since then, the taxpayer-funded broadcaster has apparently decided, not to show balance and journalistic integrity, but to delve head-first into acting as a propaganda outlet for pro-Palestinian disinformation.

Comments