On August 24, CBC twice gave a platform to Alex de Waal, a “famine scholar” and executive director of the World Peace Foundation, to discuss the UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification’s (IPC) declaration of famine in Gaza City. First on The Sunday Magazine with guest host David Common (a program we’ve long exposed for its anti-Israel bias) and later the same day on CBC News, de Waal repeated the same talking points: famine is underway, Israel is to blame, and the world must treat this as a moral stain on Israel’s conscience. What neither broadcast offered was context, balance, or a serious interrogation of de Waal’s claims.
Click below to listen to the Sunday Magazine segment:
Click below to watch the CBC News segment:
The problem is not that famine is unimportant — it is that CBC and its guest presented conjecture as fact, data as settled when it is anything but, and stripped away the most basic question: who is actually responsible for the suffering of Gaza’s civilians?
De Waal spoke glowingly of the IPC’s declaration, calling it rare, serious, and a “moral call to action.” What he didn’t acknowledge is that Gaza is being held to a different standard than every other famine in the world. Typically, famine requires at least 20% of households facing extreme food shortages, 30% of children acutely malnourished, and widespread mortality linked to hunger. In Gaza, however, the IPC quietly retooled its criteria, declaring famine based on just 15% of children suffering malnutrition — a bar never applied in Yemen, Sudan, or Somalia.
If the crisis in Gaza truly were on par with those places, why the need to lower the threshold? The answer is obvious: because the standard metrics weren’t producing the results activists wanted. Instead of re-examining their assumptions, the IPC shifted the goalposts. That’s not science. It’s agenda-driven policy dressed up as technical expertise.
Even de Waal admitted the IPC lacks direct access to Gaza, instead relying on phone surveys, second-hand reports, and data funnelled through agencies operating under Hamas oversight. He conceded the worst-off households can’t even be reached by phone. Yet, instead of treating these gaps with the caution they warrant, he doubled down on sweeping claims of “rapid deterioration.” This is a familiar pattern: in March, the IPC predicted famine was imminent in northern Gaza; by June, its own follow-up report quietly walked that back, acknowledging its reliance on “multiple layers of assumptions and inference.” That correction, shockingly, barely received coverage.
CBC never pressed de Waal on this inconsistency. Nor did they ask about markets in Gaza that remain stocked with food, or reports of prices falling due to increased supply — phenomena unheard of in an actual famine. These contradictions matter. They tell us this is not a collapse of food availability but of distribution — and much of that collapse stems from Hamas looting, diversion, and black-market profiteering.
Across both interviews, Hamas was conspicuously absent. De Waal and his hosts managed to discuss famine in Gaza without once addressing the terror group’s responsibility for launching the massacres of Oct. 7, 2023, prolonging the war, or seizing aid intended for civilians. Since May alone, 10,000 aid trucks, 5,000 tons of baby food, and thousands of medical supplies have entered Gaza. Over 100,000 trucks have passed through since October 2023. Israel even invited journalists to witness shipments crossing, and distribution via the GHF. But none of this entered the CBC narrative. Instead, listeners were told that aid “stacks up at the border” due to Israeli obstruction — completely ignoring the UN’s own failures to collect, distribute, and safeguard deliveries.
This omission is not accidental. To acknowledge Hamas’ role would complicate the simple morality play de Waal and CBC wanted to tell: Israel as cruel oppressor, Palestinians as helpless victims, international agencies as noble truth-tellers and saviours. But the reality is that Hamas bears direct responsibility for embedding itself in civilian areas, from hospitals to aid convoys, ensuring civilians are put at maximum risk.
Perhaps the most disturbing part of de Waal’s comments was his framing of Israel’s actions as confirming charges of genocide at the International Court of Justice. This is not impartial analysis — it is rhetoric indistinguishable from Hamas’ own propaganda. To equate Israel’s conduct with genocide, while ignoring Hamas’ openly and explicitly genocidal charter and atrocities, is a grotesque inversion of reality.
CBC’s responsibility was to challenge these claims, not to serve as a megaphone. Why not bring on an Israeli official to respond? Why not include independent analysts who could scrutinize the IPC’s methodology or highlight evidence of Hamas’s diversion of aid? The answer is that CBC has grown comfortable offering advocacy in place of journalism when the subject is Israel.
The tragedy is that genuine suffering in Gaza is being obscured by politicized narratives. Civilians are hurting — not because Israel is withholding aid, but because Hamas has ensured aid cannot reach those most in need. Declaring famine on the basis of lowered standards, unreliable data, and Hamas-filtered reports is not humanitarianism. It is theatre.
Alex de Waal may call it a “moral call to action,” but morality built on half-truths and omissions is no morality at all. And journalism that parrots those claims without scrutiny is not journalism — it is propaganda. Canadians deserve better than a taxpayer-funded broadcaster that confuses one-sided narrative with truth.






